释“兴味”

孙超

文艺理论研究 ›› 2018, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (3) : 151-159.

PDF(1271 KB)
欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》, 2025年8月5日 星期二
PDF(1271 KB)
文艺理论研究 ›› 2018, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (3) : 151-159.
古代文论与古代文学的理论研究

释“兴味”

  • 孙超
作者信息 +

An Interpretation of “Xingwei”

  • Sun Chao
Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

“兴味”作为诗学范畴,建基于我国诗学中“兴”与“味”这一对元范畴理论之上。钟嵘连通“兴”“味”论所提出的“滋味”实即感兴之味,指感物兴情形诸诗篇而产生的含蓄蕴藉之美,这成为后出之“兴味”的基本意涵。综观古人用例,“兴味”主要指诗歌具有一种含蓄蕴藉、富有情趣,能引发读者极高兴致,能让读者回味无穷的美感。它兼有审美接受与创作发生两种指向,兼具诗学与日常两个维度,且具有强大的意涵吸附性和文体开放性,曾与同质范畴一起成为古代各体文学的普遍审美标准,在近代更一度成为小说文体批评的核心话语,初步显示了融通古今中西的能力。时至今日,“兴味”的诗学意蕴继续向各艺术领域开放。为建构我国本土化、自主性文论话语,我们应该给予它特别的关注。

Abstract

"Xingwei" is a poetic category based on the theory of "Xing" and "Wei" in Chinese poetics. Connecting "Xing" and "taste" theories, Zhong Rong put forward the theory of "Flavour", which refers to the beauty of implication in the content and situation of the poems. This became the basic meaning of "Xingwei" later. An overview ancients cases indicate that "Xingwei" mainly refers to an aesthetic feeling or experience implied in the poetry and can rouse the reader' extremely interest and enable the reader to have an endless aftertaste. It points to both aesthetic acceptance and the generation of creation, has two dimensions of poetry and daily life, and is both absorptive and open. It once became the common aesthetic standard of ancient literature together with other homogeneous categories. In modern times, it even once became the core of literary criticism, displaying the capacity of connecting the ancient and the modern, China and the West. Up to now, the poetic meaning of "Xingwei" continues to be open to all fields of art. It is worth special attention if we want to construct localized, autonomous critical discourse of China.

关键词

兴味 / 诗学范畴 / 审美接受 / 创作发生 / 审美标准 / 文论建构

Key words

Xingwei / poetic category / aesthetic reception / generation of creation / aesthetic standard / construction of literary theory

引用本文

导出引用
孙超 . 释“兴味” [J]. 文艺理论研究, 2018, 38(3): 151-159
Sun Chao . An Interpretation of “Xingwei”[J]. Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art, 2018, 38(3): 151-159

参考文献

  • 白居易:《白氏长庆集》。《四部丛刊》影日本翻宋大字本。[Bai,Juyi.Bai's Changqing Poems.Four Seires of Ancient Books.Copy of Japan Reproduction of the Song Dynasty version.]
  • 包天笑:“《小说大观》例言”,《小说大观》1(1915):1。[Bao,Tianxiao.“Introductory Remarks of Grand View of Novel.”Grand View of Novel 1(1915):1.]
  • ---:“《小说画报》短引”,《小说画报》1(1917):1。[---.“Short Quotation of Novel Pictorial.”Novel Pictorial 1(1917):1]
  • 宝鋆:《文靖公遗集》。光绪三十四年羊城刻本。[Bao,Jun.Work Collection of Sir Wenjinggong.The 1908Guangzhou Edition.]
  • 曹雪芹:《红楼梦》(上册)。北京:人民文学出版社,2008年。[Cao,Xueqin.Dream of Red Mansions.Vol.1.Beijing:People's Literature Press,2008.]
  • 陈世骧:“原兴:兼论中国文学特质”,《中国文学的抒情传统》。北京:三联书店,2015年。101-37。[Chen,Shixiang.“Decoding Xing:On Chinese Literary Characteristics.”The Lyric Tradition of Chinese Literature.Beijing:Joint Publishing,2015.101-37.]
  • 陈衍:《石遗室文集》。清刻本。[Chen,Yan.Anthology of Shiyishi.The Qing Dynasty Edition.]
  • 杜甫:《杜工部草堂诗笺》,蔡梦弼笺注。古逸丛书覆宋麻沙本。[Du,Fu.Annotated Poems of Du Fu.Cai Mengbi.Copy of the Masha Edition of the Song Dynasty from Guyi Series.]
  • 方回:《瀛奎律髓》。合肥:黄山书社,1994年。[Fang,Hui.Yingkuilvsui.Hefei:Huangshan Press,1994.]
  • 凤兮:“海上小说家漫评”,《申报·自由谈·小说特刊》1921年1月23日。[Feng,Xi.“Comments on Shanghai Novelists.”Shenbao·Free Talk·Novel Issue 1921.]
  • 傅璇琮:《唐人选唐诗新编》。西安:陕西人民教育出版社,1996年。[Fu,Xuancong.New Edition of Tang Poems Chosen by Tang People.Xi'an:Shanxi People's Education Pres,1996.]
  • 顾元镜:《九华志》。明崇祯二年刻本。[Gu,Yuanjing.Jiuhua Local Annals.Edition of 2nd-year of Chongzhen of the Ming Dynasty.]
  • 郭勋:“雍熙乐府”,《全明散曲》(第4卷),谢伯阳编。济南:齐鲁书社,1994年。[Guo,Xun.“Yongxi Yuefu Poems.”Sanqu Poetry of the Ming Dynasty.Vol.4.Ed.Xie Boyang.Jinan:Qilu Press,1994.]
  • 黄霖韩同文:《中国历代小说论著选》。南昌:江西人民出版社,2000年。[Huang,Lin,and Han Tongwen.Anthology of Chinese Novels.Nanchang:Jiangxi People's Press,2000.]
  • 黄周星:“制曲枝语”,《中国古典剧论选辑》,金艳霞、孙董霞主编。兰州:兰州大学出版社,2012年。[Huang,Zhouxing.“Zhiquzhiyu.”Classical Chinese Opera Theory Selection.Ed.Jin Yanxia,and Sun Dongxia.Lanzhou:Lanzhou University Press,2012.]
  • 冷血:“《时报》‘小说栏’发刊辞”,《时报》1904年6月12日。[Leng,Xie.“Foreword to‘Novel Column’of Shibao.”Shibao,1904-06-02.]
  • 李东阳:《李东阳集1》,周寅宾、钱振民校点。长沙:岳麓书社,2008年。[Li,Dongyang.Collection of Li Dongyang.Vol.1.Eds.Zhou Yinbin,and Qian Zhenmin.Changsha:Yuelu Press,2008.]
  • 李光:《庄简集》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Li,Guang.Zhuangjian Collection of Poetry.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 李祁:“与地理叶梅窗”,《云阳集》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Li,Qi.“For Geographer Ye Meichuang.”Yunyang Collection of Poetry.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 李中:《碧云集》。清黄丕烈士礼居影宋钞本。[Li,Zhong.Biyun Collection of Poetry.Qing Copy of the Song Edition.]
  • 刘辰翁:“答赴启”,《须溪集》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Liu,Chenweng.“Letter of Reply.”Xuxi Collection of Poetry.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 刘勰:《文心雕龙汇评》,黄霖编著。上海:上海古籍出版社,2005年。[Liu,Xie.Comments Collection on The Book of Literary Design.Ed.Huang Lin.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Press,2005.]
  • 刘壎:《水云村稿》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Liu,Xun.Manuscript of Shuiyun Village.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 楼:《攻媿集》。清武英殿聚珍版丛书本。[Lou,Yue.Gongkui Poetry Collection.Collective Series Edition of Wuying Palace of the Qing Dynasty.]
  • 陆机:“文赋”,《文选》,六臣注。《四部丛刊》影宋本。[Lu,Ji.“Wenfu.”Collected Works.Ed.Liu Chen.Copy of Four Seires of Ancient Books of the Song Edition.]
  • 陆九渊:《象山集》。《四部丛刊》影明嘉靖本。[Lu,Jiuyuan.Xiangshan Collection of Poetry.Copy of Four Seires of Ancient Books of Jiajing Edition of Ming Dynasty.]
  • 毛晋:《六十种曲》。明末毛氏汲古阁刻本。[Mao,Jin.A Collection of 60 Ancient Operas.Edition of Jiguge of Mao's in Late Ming Dynasty.]
  • 倪谦:《倪文僖集》。清武林往哲遗著本。[Ni,Qian.Niwenxi Collection of Poetry.Edition of the Qing Dynasty.]
  • 欧阳修:《欧阳修全集》,张春林编。北京:中国文史出版社,1999年。[Ouyang,Xiu.Complete Works of Ouyang Xiu.Ed.Zhang Chunlin.Beijing:China Literature and History Press,1999.]
  • 彭定求等:《全唐诗6》。郑州:中州古籍出版社,2008年。[Peng,Dingqiu,et al..Collected Poetry from the Tang Dynasty.Vol.6.Zhengzhou:Zhongzhou Ancient Books Publishing House,2008.]
  • 宋长白:《柳亭诗话》。清康熙天茁园刻本。[Song,Changbai.Liu Ting Poetry.Tianzhuoyuan Edition of Kangxi of the Qing Dynasty.]
  • 唐圭璋:《全宋词4》,北京:中华书局,1965年。[Tang,Guizhang.Complete Song Lyrics.Vol.4.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1965.]
  • 唐英:《陶人心語》。清乾隆唐寅保刻本。[Tang,Ying.Taoren Xinyu.Tang Yinbao Edition of Qianlong of the Qing Dynasty.]
  • 陶祐曾:“论小说之势力及其影响”,《二十世纪中国小说理论资料》第一卷,陈平原编。北京:北京大学出版社,1997年。246-48。[Tao,Youzeng.“The Power and Influence of Fiction.”Resources of Twentieth Century Chinese Fiction Theories.Vol.1.Ed.Chen,Pingyuan.Beijing:Peking University Press,1997.246-48.]
  • 王一川:“兴味蕴藉:中国艺术品的本土美质及其世界性意义”,《河南社会科学》2(2016):2-18。[Wang,Yichuan.“Xingwei Implication:Local Aesthetics and Worldwide Significance of Classic Chinese Art.”He'nan Social Sciences 2(2016):2-18.]
  • 王禹偁:《小畜集》。《四部丛刊》影宋本配吕无党钞本。[Wang,Yucheng.Xiaochu Collection of Poetry.Copy of Song Edition of Four Seires of Ancient Books.]
  • 谢章铤:“赌棋山庄词话”,《历代词话》(下册),张璋等编。郑州:大象出版社,2002年。[Xie,Zhangting.“Duqi Villa Poetry.”Remarks on Poetry from Various Dynasties.Volume 2.Eds.Zhang Zhang,et al..Zhengzhou:The Elephant Press,2002.]
  • 谢榛:《四溟诗话》,《历代诗话续编》。北京:中华书局,1983年。[Xie,Zhen.“Siming Poetry.”A Sequel to Remarks on Poetry from Various Dynasties.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1983.]
  • 徐念慈:“余之小说观”,《小说林》9(1908):1-8。[Xu,Nianci.“My Viewpoint on Fiction.”Novels 9(1908):1-8.]
  • ---:“《小说林》缘起”,《小说林》(1)1907:1-4。[---.“Origin of Novels”.Novels(1)1907:1-4.]
  • 许慎:《说文解字》,北京:中华书局,1963年。[Xu,Shen.Explanation and Study of Principles of Composition of Characters.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1963.]
  • 严可均:《全晋文(中册)》,北京:商务印书馆,1999年。[Yan,Kejun.Complete Literature and Culture of the Jin Dynasty.Volume 2.Beijing:The Commercial Press,1999.]
  • 严羽:《沧浪诗话》,北京:中华书局,1985年。[Yan,Yu.Canglang Remarks on Poetry.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1985.]
  • 晁说之:《晁氏客语》。宋百川学海本。[Chao,Yuezhi.Chao's Random Talk.Baichuan Xuehai Edition of the Song Dynasty.]
  • 耶律楚材:《湛然居士集》。《四部丛刊》影元钞本。[Yelu,Chucai.Zhanran's Collection of Works.Copy of the Yuan Edition of Four Seires of Ancient Books.]
  • 饮冰:“论小说与群治之关系”,《新小说》1(1902):1-8。[Liao,Qichao.“On the Relationship between Fiction and Treatment of Various Social Problems.”New Fiction 1(1902).1-8.]
  • 元好问:“与张仲杰郎中论文”,《元好问诗》,夏敬观选注。上海:商务印书馆,1940年。16-17页。[Yuan,Haowen.“A Talk on Literature with Zhang Zhongjie”.Poetrt of Yuan Haowen.Ed.Xia Jing-guan.Shanghai:The Commercial Press,1940.16-17.]
  • 袁宏道:“叙陈正甫会心集”,《袁中郎小品》,熊礼汇选注。北京:文化艺术出版社,1996年。241-42页。[Yuan,Hongdao.“Preface to Chen Zhengfu's Huixin Work Collection.”Essays of Yuan Hongdao.Annotated.Xiong Lihui.Beijing:Culture and Art Publishing House,1996.241-42.]
  • 张岱:“答袁箨庵”,《琅嬛文集》。长沙:岳麓书社,1985年。143-44页。[Zhang,Dai.“Reply to Yuan Tuo'an.”Langhuan Anthology.Changsha:Yuelu Press,1985.143-44.]
  • 章潢:《图书编》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Zhang,Huang.About Book Compilation.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 张耒:《张耒集》(上册)。北京:中华书局,1990年。[Zhang,Lei.Zhang Lei Collection of Works.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1990.]
  • 张炎:“词源”,《词话丛编》。北京:中华书局,1986年。[Zhang,Yan.“Etymology.”Series on Poetry Comments.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1986.]
  • 赵景良:《忠义集》。文渊阁四库全书本。[Zhao,Jingliang.Zhongyi Poetry Collection.Edition of Wenyuange Siku Quanshu.]
  • 挚虞:“文章流别论”,《六朝文论讲疏》,郑在瀛著。武汉:华中理工大学出版社,1989年。64-66。[Zhi,Yu.“On Schools of Literary Works.”Talks on Literary Theories of the Six Dynasties.Ed.Zheng Zaiying.Wuhan:Huazhong University of Science and Technology Press,1989.64-66.]
  • 钟嵘:“诗品序”,《诗品译注》,周振甫译注。北京:中华书局,1998年。15-31页。[Zhong,Rong.“Preface to Poetic Aesthetics.”Translation and Annotation of Poetry Aesthetics.Ed.Zhou Zhenfu.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1998.15-31.]
  • 钟惺:《古诗归》。明闵振业三色本。[Zhong,Xing.Collection of Poetry from Ancient China to Tang Dynasty.Min Zhenye Three Color Edition of the Ming Dynasty.]
  • ---:“东坡文选序”,《隐秀轩文》,张国光点校。长沙:岳麓书社,1988年。76-78页。[---.“Preface of Selected Works of Dongpo.”Yinxiuxuanwen Selected Novels.Ed.Zhang Guoguang.Changsha:Yuelu Press,1988.76-78.]
  • 基金

    国家社科基金项目“主倡‘兴味’的民初上海小说界研究”[项目编号:15BZW122];中国博士后科学基金项目“民初小说‘兴味’观念生成与文体转变研究”[项目编号:2015M581559]的阶段性成果

    PDF(1271 KB)

    1042

    Accesses

    0

    Citation

    Detail

    段落导航
    相关文章

    /