欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》,

文艺理论研究 ›› 2012, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (4): 71-76.

• 古代文论与古代文学的理论研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

词学史论三议

夏中义   

  1. 上海交通大学中文系
  • 出版日期:2012-07-25 发布日期:2012-09-12
  • 作者简介:夏中义,教授,上海交通大学中文系,研究方向:20世纪中国文艺理论史案。

Three Arguments Relating the Study of Ci-Poetry

Xia Zhongyi   

  1. Department of Chinese Language and Literature at Shanghai Jiao Tong University
  • Online:2012-07-25 Published:2012-09-12
  • About author:Xia Zhongyi is a professor with the Department of Chinese Language and Literature at Shanghai Jiao Tong University. His main academic interest is Chinese literary theory of the 20th century.

摘要: 词作为有别于诗的体裁,具备独特的审美性能及演化路径,只有细察明辨这一点,才能历史地评价历代名家的词学见识及囿限。“词为合乐之诗”这一公案,可从“以辞证乐”的角度加以证实。其合法性在于,“词乐”所蕴藉凝结的生命意绪和审美情趣,也铭刻于历代词集、诗话、笔记和史籍中,故曲谱虽失,仍可遍考文辞间接求之。“诗—乐矛盾”是词体演化的内在动力。欧阳炯、苏轼、李清照三家作为晚唐至南宋间词论之代表,在演绎各自对“诗—乐矛盾”的立场之时,展现了一种辩证的相互关系。

关键词: 词学, 词论, 史论, 以辞证乐, 诗乐矛盾

Abstract: Chinese ci-poetry as a different poetic form from shi-poetry has its distinctive aesthetic characteristics and a unique pattern of stylistic innovation. A full understanding of this claim is essential to a historical analysis and evaluation of the theorectical commentaries on ci-poetry from the ancient famous scholars. The famous claim that ci-poetry is but shi-poetry set to music can be investigated from the perspective of "verifying the music from the lyrics," and its legitimacy lies on the one hand in the aesthetic sentiments and the life-disposition complexity in lyrics-music complex and on the other hand in various anthologies, commentaries, reading notes and historical records, despite the lack or loss of music. The poetry-music contradiction provides an internal dynamics to the stylistic innovation of ci-poetry, and a dialectical interrelationship can be found in the attitude towards this contradiction in OuYang Jiong, Su Shi and Li Qingzhao, who were three the representative ci-poets from the Late Tang Dynasty and the Southern Song Dynasty.

Key words: study of ci-poetry, ci-poetry criticism, theory of historical study, verifying the music through the lyrics, the poetry-music contradiction