欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》,

文艺理论研究 ›› 2023, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (4): 39-48.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

民国史家的中国戏曲演进路径设计与模式治史

  

  1. 上海戏剧学院戏剧文学系
  • 出版日期:2023-09-21 发布日期:2023-09-23
  • 基金资助:
    本文系国家社科基金艺术学一般项目“中国戏曲史编纂研究(1921—2021)”[项目编号:22BB034]、上海市教委“曙光计划”项目“当代中国戏曲论争研究”[项目编号:21SG48]、上海戏剧学院“华山英才支持计划”的阶段性成果。

The Design of Evolutionary Trajectories in Chinese Ancient Opera by Historians of the Republican Era and the Model Directed Approach to History

  1. the Institute of Arts, Shanghai Theatre Academy
  • Online:2023-09-21 Published:2023-09-23
  • Supported by:
    This paper is supported by the General Project of National Social Sciences Fund on Arts [22BB034]、“Shuguang Project” of Shanghai Municipal Education Commission [21SG48] and “Huashan Talent Program” of STA.

摘要: “模式”思维将戏曲史转化为一个简明的时空连续体。戏曲史编纂本质上属于模式治史。“模式”的成型经过,也是戏曲史家认知戏曲史内在机制的过程。戏曲史观的差异是戏曲史述呈现不同治史模式的根本原因。通过考察民国时期诞生的中国戏曲史著所设计、所呈现的历史图景,我们发现隐藏在历史书写具体内容和体例安排中的治史模式,主要有如下四种:要素汇聚模式、文体模式、曲模式、剧模式。不同治史模式提供了不同的戏曲历史阐释。戏曲史模式作为戏曲史构思的基始,是理解和解释戏曲史的元话语。它能够为戏曲史讲述提供一种直观而又利于理解的模型,依靠这一模式,戏曲繁复历史的言说不再遥不可及,戏曲史被简化而呈现出一条清晰的主体脉络。正是依赖“模式”的整合,尘封的戏曲史料“开口讲话”,作为有意味的组织体传达史家的意图。

关键词: 民国, 戏曲史家, 演进路径, 模式治史

Abstract: The incorporation of the “model” concept in the study of Chinese ancient opera condenses its history into a concise spatiotemporal continuum, aligning the historiography of Chinese ancient opera with model-directed approach to history. The development of these models is a process through which the historians in this field comprehend the internal mechanisms of Chinese opera's evolution. The divergent conceptualizations of Chinese ancient opera history form the fundamental basis for different approaches to constructing models in the historiography. When examining the historical landscapes depicted and presented in studies during the Republican era, we can identify four main models evident in the specific contents and arrangements within historiographical writings: the model of element convergence, style-centered model, music-centered model, and drama-centered model. These diverse historiographical models offer distinct interpretations of Chinese ancient opera's history and establish the groundwork for conceptualizing its historical development. They serve as the meta-discourse for understanding and interpreting this history. Consequently, these models provide an intuitive and easily comprehensible framework for narrating the history of Chinese ancient opera, facilitating a more accessible presentation through a clear structure. By relying on integrated models, the historical materials of Chinese ancient opera gain significance as organized entities and can effectively convey the intentions of scholars.

Key words: The Republican Era of China, Historian on Chinese Ancient Opera, Trajectory of Evolution, Model directed historiography