欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》,

文艺理论研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (2): 194-204.

• 古代文论与古代文学的理论研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

关于王维“禅境诗”诸特征之跨文化比较研究——基于王维、松尾芭蕉及海德格尔诗作的对比分析而论

孟令兵   

  1. 上海交通大学人文学院中国语言文学系
  • 出版日期:2022-04-25 发布日期:2022-05-06
  • 作者简介:孟令兵,哲学博士,上海交通大学中文系讲师,主要从事中国传统哲学研究。

A Cross-Cultural Comparative Study of the Characteristics of Wang Wei’s “Zen-Style Poetry”: A Reading of Wang Wei against Matsuo Bashō and Martin Heidegger’s Poems

Meng Lingbing   

  1.  the Department of Chinese Language and Literature, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
  • Online:2022-04-25 Published:2022-05-06
  • About author:Meng Lingbing, Ph.D., is a lecturer at the Department of Chinese Language and Literature, Shanghai Jiao Tong University. His research interest includes classical Chinese philosophy.

摘要: 本文以王维《辋川集》的五言绝句、松尾芭蕉的俳句以及海德格尔晚年诗作作为分析对象,在结合禅宗核心思想、松尾芭蕉风雅之寂以及海德格尔后期对“存在的真理”之思的基础上,概括总结此类“禅境诗”的一些的共同特征:以极其简洁的文字和近乎白描的手法,展示“刹那涌现”“法尔自然”“自存独化”的自然景象,其以禅宗思想而论则是表现诗人当下无分别意识的现量境,尤其符合王夫之对于现量境之诸要义的归纳及“云门三关”说,也与舍尔巴茨基对于现量境(“点刹那”)的分析对应相似,其所表现的是当下唯一真实存在的宇宙大化流行不息的生命力;在松尾芭蕉则符合俳艺的“闲寂”“诚”“本情”之主要思想特征;在海德格尔则体现为人如何凭借“诗”“语言”或“艺术”而进入“存在之澄明”境界、诗意化的栖居于世的诗化哲学思想。而作为此类禅境诗之魂的禅宗的现量境思想则是贯穿以上诸家思想的主要线索,于中显见实际创宗于七世纪中国唐朝慧能的禅宗思想已然贯通中西方而成为20世纪现代世界思想史共享的思想文化遗产。同时,本文也认为应该将这类“禅境诗”在古典诗歌分类中独标一格,以确立其在诗歌美学与人类哲学思想史上的不朽的永恒价值。

关键词:

王维, 禅境诗, 海德格尔, 松尾芭蕉, 俳句

Abstract: This article analyzes the five-character quatrains in Wang Wei’s Collected Poetry from Wangchuan, Matsuo Bashō’s haiku, and Martin Heidegger’s poems in his later years. The paper summaries some common features of the Zen-style poetry from the perspectives of the core ideas of Zen Buddhism, Matsuo Bashō’s wabi-sabi, and Heidegger’s later comments on “the truth of existence.”. This style of poetry uses laconic diction and near plain sketch technique to present a natural scene that is instant and self-existing while the ideas of Zen Buddhism informs the poet’s direct sensory perception (pratyakṣa-pramāṇa) that does not discriminate, which aligns with Wang Fuzhi’s summary of the essentials of the direct perception and Yunmen Zen Branch’s concept of three realms as well as Fyodor Ippolitovich Stcherbatsky’s view of point-instant (ksana), and therefore arguably it is the one and only existence of the flowing cosmic vitality that it really expresses. In Matsuo Bashō’s art of haiku, it is expressed as wabi-sabi, “sincerity” and “genuine emotion,” while the poetic philosophical thought of Heidegger, it is expressed as the realm of clarity of existence and poetic dwelling through “poetry”, “language” or “art.” Direct sensory perception, as the core of this kind of Zen-style poetry, underlies all of the above-mentioned three, but it actually displayed in seventh-century Master Huineng’s thought and becomes shared intellectual and cultural heritage of the twentieth-century modern world. The paper maintains that Zen-style poetry should be considered a subgenre so as to highlight its unique value in the history of poetic aesthetics and human philosophy.

Key words: Wang Wei, Zen-style poetry, Martin Heidegger, Matsuo Bashō; haiku