姿态的诗学：阿甘本的生命政治批评

文艺理论研究

姿态的诗学：阿甘本的生命政治批评

支运波

上海戏剧学院艺术研究所，南京大学哲学系

出版日期:2018-03-25 发布日期:2018-10-19
作者简介:支运波，上海戏剧学院艺术研究所副教授，南京大学哲学系在站博士后，主要从事艺术学理论与生命政治理论研究。
基金资助:
上海市“曙光学者”项目“生命政治理论美学的批判性研究”[项目编号：17SG48]； “上海市教育委员会高原学科建设计划Ⅱ高原上海戏剧学院艺术学理论”；中国博士后科学基金面上资助“生命政治理论视阈中的生存美学研究”[项目编号：2016M590433]的阶段性成果

Poetics of Gesture: Agamben's Biopolitical Criticism

Zhi Yunbo

the Arts Research Institute, Shanghai Theatre Academy Nanjing University

Online:2018-03-25 Published:2018-10-19
About author:Zhi Yunbo is an associate professor in the Arts Research Institute, Shanghai Theatre Academy, and a post-doctoral fellow in Nanjing University, with main academic interest in art theory and biopolitical theory.
Supported by:
the "Shuguang Program" of Shanghai Education Development Foundation (17SG48), the Shanghai Education Development Foundation for Discipline Construction by Shanghai Municipal Education Commission, and China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2016M590433)

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文旨在探究阿甘本思想中姿态批评的相关内容，澄清姿态批评何以属于政治与伦理的生命政治理论论域的根据。文章分为三部分：第一部分勾勒阿甘本有关哑口、空无和纯粹媒介的姿态维度，指出其悬置批评传统，重新勘定新的批评边界的革命性批评意义；第二部分阐明姿态也是阿甘本的思想来源者本雅明文学批评的主要概念，并论述中断作为本雅明姿态论的内容及价值；最后一个部分阐释作为生命政治批评范畴的姿态论。本文的结论为姿态论是阿甘本文学批评的根本思想，并由此标志着其文学批评从美学批评向生命政治批评的深度越界与重大转向。

关键词: 阿甘本, 本雅明, 姿态, 生命政治批评

Abstract: This article explores the gestural criticism in Agamben's works and elucidates why it belongs to the biopolitical criticism of politics or ethics. This article has three sections. First, it discusses the dimensions of gesture, gag, emptiness, and pure medium, and then points out that gestural criticism's revolutionary significance in terms of suspending the critical tradition and resetting a new boundary for criticism. Second, it illuminates that gesture is also a key critical concept of Benjamin's, and then discusses the meaning and value of interruption in gesture. Third, this article illustrates that the theory of gesture belongs to biopolitical criticism. This article concludes that gesture is fundamental to Agamben's critical thought, which indicates a turn from aesthetic criticism to biopolitical criticism.

Key words: Agamben, Benjamin, gesture, biopolitical criticism

支运波 . 姿态的诗学：阿甘本的生命政治批评[J]. 文艺理论研究.

Zhi Yunbo . Poetics of Gesture: Agamben's Biopolitical Criticism[J]. Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art.

[1]Agamben, Giorgio.Means Without End.Trans.Vincenzo Binetti and Cesare Casarino.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press, 2000. [2]吉奥乔·阿甘本:《亵渎》, 王立秋译, 芬雷校。泼先生书籍, 2012年。[---.Profanations.Trans.Wang Liqiu.Pulsasir, 2012.] [3]---:《无目的的手段:政治学笔记》, 赵文译。郑州:河南大学出版社, 2015年。[---.Means Without End:Notes on Politics.Trans.Zhao Wen.Zhengzhou:Henan University Press, 2015.] [4]---:《潜能》, 王立秋等译, 沙明校。桂林:漓江出版社, 2014年。[---.Potentialities:Collected Essays in Philosophy.Trans.Wang Liqiu, et al..Guilin:Lijiang Publishing, 2014.] [5]汉娜·阿伦特编:《启迪:本雅明文选》, 张旭东、王斑译。北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店, 2016年。[Arendt, Hannah, ed.Illuminations:Selected Works of Walter Benjamin.Trans.Zhang Xudong and Wang Ban.Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2016.] [6]Benjamin, Walter.Understanding Brecht.Trans.Anna Bostock.London and New York:Verso, 2003. [7]瓦尔特·本雅明:《波德莱尔:发达资本主义时代的抒情诗人》, 王涌译。南京:译林出版社, 2014年。[---.Baudelaire:A Lyric Poet in the Era of High Capitalism.Trans.Wang Yong.Nanjing:Yilin Press, 2014.] [8]---:《开箱整理我的藏书:本雅明读书随笔》, 张佐臣等译。北京:金城出版社, 2014年。[---.Unpacking My Library.Trans.Zhang Zuochen, et al..Beijing:Gold Wall Press, 2014.] [9]---:“瓦尔特·本雅明论广播”, 库岑译。《热风学术网刊》1 (2016) :73-79。[---.“Radio Benjamin.”Trans.Ku Cen.Hot Wind Forum1 (2016) :73-79. [10]Bos, Renéten.“On the Possibility of Formless Life:Agamben's Politics of the Gesture.”Theory and Politics in Organization 5.1 (2005) :26-44. [11]Colilli, Paul.Agamben and the Signature of Astrology:Spheres of Potentiality.New York:Lexington Books, 2015. [12]Dicknson, Colby.“Beyond Violence, Beyond the Text:The Role of Gesture in Walter Benjamin and Giorgio Agamben, and Its Affinity with the Work of RenéGirard.”The Heythrop Journal 52.6 (2011) :952-61. [13]Foucault, Michel.Language, Counter-Memory, Practice:Selected Essays and Interview.Trans.D.Bouchard and Sherry Simon.Ithaca:Cornell University Press, 1980. [14]Fleming, Paul.“The Crisis of Art:Max Kommerell and Jean Paul's Gestures.”MLN 115.3 (2000) :519-43. [15]Gustafsson, Henrik, and Asbjrn Grnstad.Cinema and Agamben:Ethics, Biopolitics and the Moving Image.New York:Bloomsbury Academic, 2014. [16]Harbord, Janet.“Agamben's Cinema:Psychology Versus an Ethical Form of Life.”European Journal of Media Studies 4.2 (2015) :13-30. [17]Kendon, Adam.“The Study of Gesture:Some Observations on Its History.”Semiotic Inquiry 2.1 (1982) :44-62. [18]伊斯特·莱斯利:《本雅明》, 陈永国译。北京:北京大学出版社, 2013年。[Leslie, Esther.Benjamin.Trans.Chen Yongguo.Beijing:Peking University Press, 2013.] [19]Murray, Alex, and Jessica Whyte.The Agamben Dictionary.Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press, 2011. [20]艾利克斯·穆雷:《论阿甘本》, 王立秋译, 芬雷校。泼先生书籍, 2012年。[Murray, Alex.Giorgio Agamben.Trans.Wang Liqiu.Pulsasir, 2012.] [21]Clemens, Justin, Nicholas Heron, and Alex Murray.The Work of Giorgio Agamben:Law, Literature, Life.Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press, 2008. [22]让-吕克·南希:《无用的共同体》, 郭建玲等译。郑州:河南大学出版社, 2016年。[Nancy, Jean-Luc.The Inoperative Community.Trans.Guo Jianling, et al..Zhengzhou:Henan University Press, 2016.] [23]Ruprecht, Lucia.“Gesture, Interruption, Vibration:Rethinking Early Twentieth-Century Gestural Theory and Practice in Walter Benjamin, Rudolf von Laban, and Mary Wigman.”Dance Research Journal 47.2 (2015) :23-42. [24]Weber, Samue.“Going Along for the Ride:Violence and Gesture:Agamben Reading Benjamin Reading Kafka Reading Cervantes.”The Germanic Review:Literature, Culture, Theory 81.1 (2006) :65-83.