欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》,

文艺理论研究 ›› 2021, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (2): 26-32.

• 专题:京剧研究专题 • 上一篇    下一篇

看似平易实艰辛——五四反思与王元化京剧观的形成

李伟   

  1. 上海戏剧学院
  • 出版日期:2021-03-25 发布日期:2021-03-23
  • 作者简介:李伟,南京大学文学博士,上海戏剧学院教授。主要从事戏剧理论与批评、20世纪中国戏剧研究。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金艺术学重大项目“戏曲现代戏创作研究”[项目编号:18ZD05]

On Wang Yuanhua's Ideas of Jingju and His Reflection on the May Fourth Movement 

Li Wei   

  1. Shanghai Theatre Academy
  • Online:2021-03-25 Published:2021-03-23
  • About author:Li Wei, Ph.D., is a professor at Shanghai Theatre Academy. His research interests cover dramatic theory and criticism and Chinese theatre in the 20th century.
  • Supported by:
    Major Project of National Social Sciences Fund for Art (18ZD05)

摘要: 在王元化百年诞辰之际重温他的京剧观,特别有意义。他从文化传承的角度对京剧的振兴与发展所作的思考很有价值。他认为在道德观念上,京剧是中国文化大传统向小传统传播的媒介、载体;从表演体系看,京剧体现了中国传统艺术的比兴的思维方式、心物交融的抒情方式和在创作与欣赏中善入善出的行为方式,形成了“虚拟化、程式化、写意型”的完整体系。因此京剧的振兴与发展应当坚持在继承基础上创新的方针。王元化的京剧观的形成经历了漫长的过程,主要是在“五四”反思的基础上,对“五四”新旧戏剧论争以及新中国戏曲改革实践进行反思的结果。尽管关于京剧改革的议题,王元化的思考尚有引而不发、破而未立之处,但这并不妨碍我们沿着他的思考继续探索。

关键词: 王元化, 京剧观, 道德观念, 表演体系, 戏曲改革

Abstract: It is extremely meaningful, on the occasion of the hundredth anniversary of Wang Yuanhua’s birth, to restudy his ideas of jingju. Wang’s thoughts on the revival and development of jingju from the perspective of cultural heritage are highly valuable. He believes that, in terms of moral ideas, jingju is a medium and vehicle in disseminating grand traditions of Chinese culture towards smaller traditions. Meanwhile, considered as a performance system, jingju embodies the “bixing” mindset, the lyrical expression with mind-object interaction, as well as the flexible distance-immersion dynamic among performers and spectators. This results in a complete system of virtuality, conventionalization, and ideographics . He therefore maintains that the guideline of the revival and development of jingju should be innovation based on inheritance. Wang’s views on jingju, which underwent an enduring process, primarily stemmed from his reflections on the controversy of new and old theatre during the May Fourth Movement and the subsequent reforms and new practices in xiqu. Although Wang’s thoughts on jingju reform are more preliminary than active, less constructive than destructive, they indeed point a direction for further reflection. 

Key words: Wang Yuanhua, ideas of jingju, moral ideas, performance system; xiqu reform