Welcome to Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art,

Archive

  • Select all
    |
    Issue in Focus:Theory of Narratology
  • Issue in Focus:Theory of Narratology
    Cao Danhong
    2023, 43(4): 1-9.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Since the 1980s, the question of fictionality has been a major focus of Western scholarship. A variety of theoretical and methodological approaches have emerged, among which the most representative are the works of Thomas Pavel, Kendall Walton,  Genette, Marie-Laure Ryan, Lubomír Dolezel, Dorrit Cohn, and Jean-Marie Schaeffer. Studies of fictionality can be divided into three categories: studies of the internal such as ontological and formalist methods, studies of the external such as those adopting the perspectives of pragmatics and cognitive science, and research that combines these two approaches. These studies have shaped the primary orientations and tendencies in the study of fictionality in the West, namely, the transmedia perspective, the synthetic approach that integrates the internal and external methods, and intercultural and historical perspectives that aim to capture the cultural diversity and historicity of the concept. In general, contemporary Western research on fictionality seeks to better understand the varied relationships between cultures of fiction and their corresponding societies, and to reinforce fiction's role in an anthropological sense.
  • Issue in Focus:Theory of Narratology
    Zeng Wei
    2023, 43(4): 10-18.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Literary adaptation involves the transformation and reshaping of media symbols based on literary works. This phenomenon has garnered significant attention from critics and theorists, leading to the development of adaptation theory. Linda Hutcheon, drawing upon the analytical framework of communication studies, conceptualizes adaptation as a process of recoding the source text through media. In this regard, she outlines three models of adaptation: telling, showing and interacting. However, when considering the audiences experience within the adapted story world, these models can be modified to reflect the roles of imagination, cognition and participation. These adaptations align with the evolving nature of media, progressing from a single medium to multimedia and eventually converging media or hypermedia, mirroring the technological advancements in the media landscape. While media development seemingly caters to the audience's desire for sensory pleasure, it also encroaches upon their imaginative space. Technical prostheses divert attention away from the original story world and the real world. Therefore, in literary adaptations it is crucial to adopt a cautious and critical stance towards media technology, utilizing it judiciously, giving full play to the creativity of the individual, and offering the audience highquality, stylistically rich and intellectually engaging works of art.
  • Issue in Focus:Theory of Narratology
    2023, 43(4): 19-30.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
     There is a phenomenon where a significant number of actual audience members actively participate and intervene in the narrative process during narrative activities. It is true that the field of narratology often leans towards a “text-centered” and “narrator-centered” approach, neglecting the examination of the real audience's role. Existing research on the real audience mainly focuses on areas such as reading and viewing psychology, audience consumption surveys, and similar aspects. Similarly, in the realm of performing arts, particularly drama, the emphasis is often placed on the performance itself rather than exploring the relationship between the real audience and the narrative. This leads to the exclusion of the real audience from the study of narratology. Incorporating the real audience into narrative analysis requires a shift from a “closed text” to an “open work” perspective. It involves recognizing the different types and roles of the real audience in various art forms and moving away from traditional, closed narrative frameworks towards an “open narrative” approach. By incorporating the concept of “theatricality” into the audience-narrative relationship, existing theories of “narrative process” and “narrative intervention” can be reexamined. This allows for a differentiation of the real audience's intervention in the narrative process into “intervention in the real narrative process” and “intervention in the fictional narrative process”. This perspective opens up possibilities for exploring the development of a narrative theory that is shaped by the active participation of the real audience.

  • Issue in Focus: Literary History Studies
  • Issue in Focus: Literary History Studies
    Liu Songlai, Gao Cuiyuan
    2023, 43(4): 31-39.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Chinese literary history has been dominated by an excessive emphasis on knowledge and scientism, with comparatively little attention given to aesthetics. However, Lin Geng's literary history stands out due to its remarkable focus on the aesthetic aspects of literature and its unique interpretation of the artistic appeal of literary works. Lin Geng's approach to literary history writing is rooted in his aesthetic theory of life, which demonstrates his profound understanding of aesthetic transcendence and underscores his recognition of the significance of the linguistic form in literature. As such, Lin Geng's literary history writings serve as a useful model for the incorporation of aesthetics into Chinese literary historigraphy.
  • Huang Jingfeng
    2023, 43(4): 39-48.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    The incorporation of the “model” concept in the study of Chinese ancient opera condenses its history into a concise spatiotemporal continuum, aligning the historiography of Chinese ancient opera with model-directed approach to history. The development of these models is a process through which the historians in this field comprehend the internal mechanisms of Chinese opera's evolution. The divergent conceptualizations of Chinese ancient opera history form the fundamental basis for different approaches to constructing models in the historiography. When examining the historical landscapes depicted and presented in studies during the Republican era, we can identify four main models evident in the specific contents and arrangements within historiographical writings: the model of element convergence, style-centered model, music-centered model, and drama-centered model. These diverse historiographical models offer distinct interpretations of Chinese ancient opera's history and establish the groundwork for conceptualizing its historical development. They serve as the meta-discourse for understanding and interpreting this history. Consequently, these models provide an intuitive and easily comprehensible framework for narrating the history of Chinese ancient opera, facilitating a more accessible presentation through a clear structure. By relying on integrated models, the historical materials of Chinese ancient opera gain significance as organized entities and can effectively convey the intentions of scholars.
  • Issue in Focus: Literary History Studies
  • Issue in Focus: Literary History Studies
    Liu Xiangyu
    2023, 43(4): 49-60.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Tan Zhengbi conducted a thorough textual research on the quantity, remnants, and content of vernacular stories from the Song and Yuan Dynasties. His work involved distinguishing between The Vernacular Stories from Qingpingshan Hall and the vernacular stories 3-Words and 2-Slaps, accurately attributing them to their respective historical periods. Tan Zhengbi's study of vernacular stories in the Song and Yuan Dynasties not only prioritized the essence and origin of these stories but also recognized the significance of their interplay and influence with other artistic forms. His renowned work A History of Chinese Fiction Development, Tan Zhengbi assimilated the latest research findings from the academic community, establishing his own comprehensive theoretical framework. His academic accomplishments were not only associated with the intellectual trends of the May 4th New Culture Movement but also reflective of his determined attitude towards self-improvement and his unwavering work ethic.
  • Issue in Focus: Reading as Compassion
  • Issue in Focus: Reading as Compassion
    Yue Zhuo
    2023, 43(4): 61-69.
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
    Tuo Jianqing
    2023, 43(4): 82-92.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Robert T. Tally Jr.'s theory of literary cartography, a development based on Frederic Jameson's notion of cognitive mapping, differentiates itself from the concept of literary maps which focuses on the distinction between text and map. Tally's literary cartography not only engages the fundamental connection between human existence, topophrenia, and literary cartography, but also reveals the inherent characteristics of literary cartography such as spatiality, metaphorization and ideological productivity. As an approach to understanding the modern world through the lens of text as map, literary cartography not only introduces new perspectives and methodology to literary studies and geocriticism, but also turns to the study of human existence. Conceived as a way to create authentic space and overcome spatial anxiety and representational crisis, literary cartography has switched from merely drawing literary maps to creating maps of people's lives. Tally's literary cartography projects a map of human existence through literary mapping, for the sake of humans' well-being.
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
    Zhang Wenying
    2023, 43(4): 93-103.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Embarking on the paradox of the imagination, Schelling elaborates on its creative and intuitive nature. He regards the intellectual intuition of the Absolute as the transcendental foundation of imagination, thus elevating the latter from the level of epistemology to that of ontology, and making it a kind of creativity rooted in the divine Creation that establishes the fundamental relationship between human and the being of the world. The poetic imagination is the objectification of the divine imagination in the empirical world. It communicates the finite and the infinite through the aesthetic action of “Ein-bildung,” and achieves the realization of the Absolute's self-production and self-intuition. The integration of imagination and the metaphysical construction principle of the whole philosophical system is essentially a poetic creation. The inherent structure of imagination contains a contradiction between freedom and necessity. Schelling believes that the real imagination should be free creation constrained by systematic inner necessity. He reveals the real human imagination as the combination of divinity and poetry based on human freedom. The three-dimensional theoretical structure of imagination—divinity, poetry and freedom—runs through the three human spiritual fields, reason, sensibility and will, which correspond to the triple meta-value of truth, beauty and goodness, prompting people to achieve an overall harmonious state of life.
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
    Li Tian
    2023, 43(4): 104-114.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Based on such phenomenological categories as perception and body, Paul Virilio's critical analysis of modernity displays some unusual features. Different from Jean Baudrillard's theory of simulation that ontologically denies reality, Virilio maintains that there are generations of realities, which implies that reality itself does not dissolve but is replaced by other realities. Virilio further develops a critique of modernity focusing on “speed” and constructs his philosophy of speed. He argues that speed creates new dimensions of time and space and that the social structure is thus changed through the change of bodily perception. In modern society, digital technology uses the visual-audio vehicles running at the speed of light to create tele-presence, polar inertia and mediated perception, which dissolve and dispel people's real perception and worldly experience. Virilio vehemently criticizes contemporary technology for it leads to the “doomsday” crisis of modern society. This article follows the phenomenological path of Virilio to rethink his philosophy of speed, in order to discuss the close connection between his intensive critical style and hidden nature of technology.
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
    Ai Xin
    2023, 43(4): 105.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    After finishing Black Square, the foundation for pure abstract art, Kazimir Malevich sought to further consolidate and develop the connotation of suprematism, using the “zero of form” as a core principle to deepen his metaphysical thinking about color. In his theoretical writings and artistic practice from 1915 to 1920, Malevich developed the concept of artistic evolution, namely “three stages of suprematism” (black–red–white), endowing each stage with a corresponding motivation (economy–revolution–pure action). Malevich saw White on White, which contained universal utopian ideas, as the final stage of Hegel's evolutionary view of history, in which the concepts were integrated into a purely unified form and became self-contained, corresponding to what Malevich referred to as the “unified world architectural system on Earth” or the “post-historical” era of art. Combining Arthur Danto's declaration of the “end of art”, painting has come to an end in the narrative level in White on White, where both form and color are “transformed into zero,” and the interpretation of artistic concepts turn into the interpretation of philosophical concepts. However, abstract art has entered a diversified era in the theoretical atmosphere of the “art world,” and the “emptiness” of abstract art has the potential to continue to nurture or generate new connotations and ideas. The “end of art” in the context of suprematism emphasizes the “liberation” of art in the dual sense of aesthetic and social values, which is closely related to the aesthetics of the Russian Silver Age.
  • Western Literary Theory and Aesthetics Studies
    Chu Min
    2023, 43(4): 127-136.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Jerrold Levinson insists on hypothetical intentionalism (HI) in the interpretation of literary works, arguing that the meaning of a literary work is the appropriate readers-optimal hypothetical projection of the author's most probable intentions based on the historical context wherein the text was produced. Levinson distinguishes four kinds of meanings by referencing to and perfecting Tolhurst's theory. In terms of the ontology of literary works, Levinson distinguishes works and texts, comparing his theory with Iseminger's. Levinson also differentiates categorical intention from semantic intention, refuting Lyas's Neo-Wittgenstein view. The distinctions between ordinary communication and literary communication are also clarified when Levinson negotiates with Carroll's actual intentionalism. In these encounters with different theories, Levinson reiterates the importance of context, hypothetical relationships, utterance meaning and the qualities of interpreters. He debates with Stephen Davies and Robert Stecker on some of the mis-conceptualizations of his theory. Levinson's HI is a reasonable alternative to extreme intentionalism and anti-intentionalism. As a pluralist theory of interpretation, HI enables the work to carry multiple meanings full of possibilities, creating an open space for interpretation. Such theory also sets a high threshold for criticism and urges the interpreter to constantly enhance their qualifications.
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
    Cai Zongqi
    2023, 43(4): 137-145.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Inspired by the opposing views of emotion held by William Wordsworth and T. S. Eliot, this article establishes a new theoretical framework for examining the Chinese lyrical tradition, one that is grounded in emotion's interrelations with events, belletristic texts, and authorial disposition. Following the turn toward a positive review of emotion during the Han, a political event-oriented view of emotion emerged, as explicitly articulated in the “Preface to the Book of Poetry.” During the ensuing Six Dynasties period, emotion was reconceptualized as that of which refined literature is constituted. Critical attention was turned to the interaction of emotion with images and words in the process of literary creation. During the Tang dynasty, Bai Juyi engineered an integration of the Han politically focused view and the Six Dynasties belletristically focused views of emotion. While employing poetry as a means of political and social criticism, he took delight in composing works primarily for the sake of aesthetic pleasure. With the Song and Yuan critics, the author's disposition, often interpreted in moralistic terms, became the new focus of expositions on emotion. Taken together as a whole, expositions on emotion in traditional Chinese poetics attest to a highly coherent system of literary thought on emotion, characterized by the sharing of the common denominator of expressionism as well as the divergent emphasis on politics, aesthetics, and morality. As this system of literary thought continued to evolve over the millennia, it seems appropriate to regard it as a lyrical tradition in its own right.
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
    Sun Shaohua
    2023, 43(4): 146-153.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    The fluidity of ancient Chinese texts results in the transformation of a certain text as well as the possibility for the text to be adapted, continued or rewritten, thus forming different “textual clusters.” In this process, the “historical value” and “didactic function” of the text also change accordingly. In Elucidation of Fu of The Literary Mind and the Carving of Dragons, Liu Xie listed eight fu masters in the Western Han dynasty. Lu Jia, Mei Gao and Dongfang Shuo were included as famous fu masters thanks to the construction by later generations, which embodied the features of “fluidity of texts” and “construction of fu authors.” From a theoretical perspective, this phenomenon also reflected the profound social meaning behind the text.
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
    Wang Linfu
    2023, 43(4): 154-161.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Calling melody as pai first appeared in the middle of the Ming dynasty, which is a fascinating phenomenon in Chinas cultural history. Paiming was a term particularly used by scholars in the Ming and Qing dynasties, whose original meaning represented the names in card games. As the use of terms in card games and classical melody tended to be similar, the names of cards were adopted as the names of melody during drinking games. Cipai and qupai were derivative words of paiming, which became popular at a later time. The primary cause for this phenomenon was the need for expression. As specific nouns to represent the melody of drama were absent, the term qupai was more readily accepted. The introduction of cipai into the study of ci-poetry resulted from the fact that “the melody of ci-poetry” could also refer to musical mode. The term pai can better express the stylistic characteristics of ci and qu genres.
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
    Yang Jihua
    2023, 43(4): 162-171.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Xin Qiji embodied the unique duality of his identity as a literati and a scholar official,” allowing it to express both his pursuit of political values in the social realm and his personal experience in realistic situations. This distinctive style combines elements of restraint and unhibited expressioncoexist, showcasing the diversity of Xin Qiji's literati identity. His ci-poetry holds significant textual importance in the history of literati ci-poetry. By upholding the tradition of “writing ci-poetry according to sound” while expanding the artistic capacity and lyrical function of ci-poetry, Xin Qiji surpassed the stylistic boundaries between poetry and ci-poetry. Through the skillful utilization of traditional artistic techniques, he established the literary status of ci-poetry as a language based art form. Additionally, Xin Qiji effectively reconciled the musical and literary aspects of ci-poetry, resolving the challenge of using the conventional ci-poetry form to express the novel content of “ambition.” This accomplishment greatly influences the development of literati ci poetry. Xin Qiji's ci-poetry not only serves as a literary representation of the historical, social and cultural dynamics between the Northern Song Dynasty and the Southern Song Dynasty but also enriches the possibilities for the pluralistic characteristics of the literary essence of ci-poetry.
  • Ancient Chinese Literary Theory and Theoretical Studies on Ancient Chinese Literature
    Fu Xu
    2023, 43(4): 172-181.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    Zhang Xuecheng introduced the idea that “classical prose doesn't derive from history, just like food doesn't come from crops” in his General Interpretations of Literature and History (Wenshi Tongyi). Within the realm of “classical prose”, narrative prose holds significance importance and finds its origins in historical events, particularly those chronicled in Spring and Autumn Annuals. These events have contributed to the establishment of the tradition of prose through the lens of the Four Treasures. Zhang's concept of “classical prose derived from history” is further evident in his practice of classical prose criticism. He incorporates historical examples to enhance the nature of narrative genres, such as biography and epitaph, while also offering critiques of the limitations imposed by societal taboos and disingenuous language. In essence, the idea of “classical prose derived from history” aligns with Zhang Xuecheng's theoretical framework, which aimed to achieve a comprehensive understanding of the Four Treasures, claiming that the “Six Arts” in the Warring State era and after. It should be noted that there exists a fundamental distinction between the positioning of “history” in the context of the Six Arts in the Warring States era and the viewing of “history” as the governing principles reflected in the notion of “Six Classics as works on governance”.
  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Tang Zhesheng
    2023, 43(4): 182-193.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    In terms of social orientation, Chinese martial arts novels of the last century demonstrate strong awareness of the modern nation, nationalism and the public. In terms of cultural form, these novels integrate traditional Chinese culture with the new culture of the May Fourth Movement. In terms of aesthetic presentation, they continue the narrative tradition of Chinese novels, fusing various new genres, creating new styles, as well as constructing a modern “martial arts aesthetic.” An evaluation of the Chinese martial arts novels of the last century is to explain their new social, cultural and aesthetic value as well as to explain how they travelled overseas and became one of the major Chinese literary genres. The evaluation is also expected to identify and correct the shortcomings of the Chinese martial arts novels of the last century. The martial arts novel is the most typical genre of Chinese popular literature, which strongly embodies Chinese tradition and national characteristics. It has enjoyed a wide readership in China since ancient times and has been passed down from generation to generation. The evaluation of the centenary Chinese martial arts novels and the reflection upon the modernity of the Chinese xia culture are of positive significance for the scientific construction of the modern Chinese literary criticism.
  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Zeng Rong, Zeng Qinhan
    2023, 43(4): 194-203.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    The heated discussion on the issue of national forms in the literary and artistic circles of Yan'an prompted the Luyi Woodcarving Work Group to pursue the national forms of revolutionary literature and art via such practices as “Sinicization” and “nationalization” of woodcarving. In the process of integrating China with the West and reconciling the old with the new, “national form” was given the double connotation of inheriting the national culture and waging a nationwide war against Japan, which laid the foundation for exploring a constructive way for the revolutionary literary theory of Yan'an. Following the Yan'an Forum on Literature and Art, the idea that literature and art should serve politics, workers, peasants, and soldiers gradually took root in the hearts of the people. As a result, the theory of revolutionary literature and art was generated in mobilizing the Chinese people to join the war effort against Japanese aggression. After the publication of Mao Zedong's “Talks at the Yan'an Forum on Literature and Art” in 1942, the work style and ideological conceptualizations of the Yan'an literary and art circles underwent a fundamental transformation. With the development of literary and artistic practices of Chinese characteristics, which were popular among the masses, the theoretical system of revolutionary literature and art was gradually constructed. The literary and artistic practices and ideological changes of the Luyi Woodcarving Work Group before and after the Yan'an Forum on Literature and Art embodied the historical developments of the construction of the system of revolutionary theory of art and literature, as well as the basic logic in the mutual evolution of the theory and practice of revolutionary art and literature.
  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Cao Qinghua
    2023, 43(4): 204-213.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save
    The image of Ah-Q in Lu Xun's writing is not a carrier of any specific “characteristics”—be it national character or revolutionary spirit—but rather embodies a unique life-world. On the one hand, the individual living being of Ah-Q, who comes from the lowest social class, has been constructed and disciplined by the dominant language system of representation, of which he is also a maintainer and practitioner. On the other hand, he is also shaped by this system into a complete “other”, and is ultimately expelled and even eliminated by the system. As an “other”, Ah-Q's basic desires, rights and social positions are not approved and protected by the system. Instead, the system relentlessly encircles Ah-Q, inflicting tremendous physical and mental damage upon him. Ah-Q's victories are a kind of radically distorted linguistic activity in the face of external encirclement and attack. As Lu Xun argued, there are no thought and “-isms” in the integral history of China, but only flashes of materialism, and Ah-Q is unable to break free from the grip of this materialistic realm.
  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Pan Jianwei
    2023, 43(4): 214-223.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save

    Chen Yan not only often incorporated vernacular neologisms into his poems but also essentially embraced the concept of “vernacular poetry” coined by Hu Shi. He made regular reference to “vernacular poetry” in his poetry commentaries, a connection closely tied to his subsequent shift in his poetics. During the early phase, Chen Yan turned to the “poetry of scholars” to rectify the deficiencies of shadow texture and howllow emotion in poetry. He advocated for the inclusion of “classics and history” to enrich the foundation of poetry. In his later period, he observed that some contemporary poems at that time deliberately relied on excessive allusions, resulting in the stifling of sensibility. He extolled the virtues of the “poetry of poets” to emphasize that poetry should convey genuine sentiments and that poets must employ their own words. Chen Yan's poetic theory contained revolutionary elments that bore a striking similarity to Hu Shi's view in “A Preliminary Discussion on Literary Reform” Furthermore, Chen Yan placed special emphasis on the musicality of poetry, aligning with the viewpoints of modernist poets on this particular matter. A comprehensive understanding of the intricate relationship between Chen Yan and the theory of new poetry can only be achieved by considering his later poetics in conjunction with the backdrop of the New Culture Movement.

  • Studies of Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Zheng Liang, Zhou Weiwei
    2023, 43(4): 224-226.
    Download PDF ( )   Knowledge map   Save