Loading...
Welcome to Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art,

Table of Content

    25 September 2019, Volume 39 Issue 5 Previous Issue    Next Issue
    For Selected: Toggle Thumbnails
    Chinese Literary Critical Discourse
    Intersemiotic Intertextuality, Verbal-Independent Visual Transcendence, and Visual Criticism: A Study of Intertextuality in the Drawing of Seven Sages of the Bamboo Grove
    Zhang Yuqin
    2019, 39 (5):  1-10. 
    Abstract ( 273 )   PDF (1340KB) ( 129 )  

    Taking intersemiotic intertextual play in the drawing of Seven Sages of the Bamboo Grove as an example, this article investigates the intertwinement between language and image, a research topic worth a theoretical discussion, too, in the area of contemporary literary theory. This drawing generated with reference to the anecdotes of "Seven Sages" in ancient China is more a cultural marker of literature and art developed during the dynasties of Wei and Jin and thereafter than the epitome of unruly and indulged refined scholars. Apart from the verbal-dependent visual intertextuality, found within the drawing is the verbal-independent transcendence of the visual, an enrichment or transgression in meaning or other possible aspects of the latter independent of the former. Labelled as a self-developmental model, this verbal-independent transcendent process lends itself well to suggesting treating the visual component per se as a useful meaning producer and transmitter, which helps direct our attention to a new important research topic in the study of literary theory and criticism.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    The Aesthetics of Parody in The Late Ming Dynasty
    Tuo Jianqing
    2019, 39 (5):  11-21. 
    Abstract ( 158 )   PDF (1341KB) ( 114 )  

    The late Ming parodic literature manifests itself as an innovated style based on the tradition of Chinese humorous literature. By means of vulgar imitation in the absurd senses of "crowning" and "de-crowning," it creates a comedic effect disagreeing with the original text and actualizes a restrained mockery of the social norm. The aim, however, is to appeal to the rationalization of human desire and the legitimatization of physical lust. The rise of aesthetic parody, on the internal level, stems from late Ming literature's conceptual shift from morality to entertainment and its narrative departure from traditional storytelling; on the external level, it is related to the emergence of consumer society and that of mass media in the late Ming dynasty. The investigation into late Ming aesthetics of parody, on the one hand, provides an intriguing case for the study of Chinese aesthetic culture; on the other hand, it signifies a reconsideration of the Western theory of parody based on the Chinese experience and further begets a possibility of rewriting the history of modern Chinese literature.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Issue in Focus: Somaesthetics Studies
    The Soma Dimension of Kant's Aesthetics and Its Significance for Ecoaesthetics
    Cheng Xiangzhan
    2019, 39 (5):  22-31. 
    Abstract ( 307 )   PDF (1756KB) ( 117 )  
    Kant's aesthetics is typical for its "mind-representation". Mind uses all kinds of cognitive faculties to represent the object as a representation through synthesis, and then the object is given subjectivity through representation. Thus the taste in mind makes aesthetic judgments by connecting the representation with the subject's feeling. Kant, however, has not elaborated on and clarified the relationship between feeling and taste, thus making his aesthetics mainly "a science of judgment" that is rational rather than "a science of feeling" that is perceptual. However, Kant also proposes "taste of the senses" against "taste of reflection" and occasionally mentions such sense organs as the tongue, the soft palate, the throat, the eyes, and the ears, all of which can be regarded as the soma dimensions of Kant's aesthetic theory. Today, it is acknowledged that all bodily senses have their own specific perceptual abilities, through which the objective world reveals itself to human beings. According to the principle of "suitability" proposed in Kant's teleological philosophy, there is a natural correspondence between human senses and objective things, with the latter revealing themselves through the former. Somaesthetics reflects and criticizes Kant's aesthetics, thereby going beyond it. In this way, somaesthetics transforms the aesthetics of "mind-representation" which ignores and conceals the thing-it-self into the aesthetics of "body-thing-it-self" which has an interest in thing-it-self and invites it to appear; and the latter one is the core concern of ecoaesthetics. From this perspective, somaesthetics is one of the best media to reverse the nonecological trend of Kant's aesthetics and then to reconstruct it as an ecological one.
    Related Articles | Metrics
    The Decline of Dualism and the Rise of Soma-esthetics in Western Aesthetics
    Wang Xiaohua
    2019, 39 (5):  32-42. 
    Abstract ( 243 )   PDF (1776KB) ( 241 )  

    Dualism has long been dominant in the history of Western aesthetics, and it has established a hierarchical schema from the day it was born. The mind is imagined as a subjective role, while the body is regarded as a passive object that needs to be driven, enriched and guided. From the point of logic, a paradox is inherent to the schema: if the body and the mind are essentially different, they cannot interact with each other; if their nature is the same in essence, it is equally illogical to distinguish them. In the process of solving this paradox, the significance of the body exposes itself, especially in the modern and post-modern times when natural science continues to reveal the attribution of mental activities to the body, providing evidence for the deconstruction of dualism. Along with the decline of dualism, the body in the modern and contemporary theories gradually assumes the subjectivity of its own, and a revival of the body develops in the new construction of aesthetics. The mid-18th century sees the aesthetics in the form of body discourse, the end of the 19th century sees Nietzsche outlining the prototype of soma-aesthetics, and the 20th century, driven by the combined efforts of phenomenology, pragmatism and cognitive science, sees soma-esthetics upgrading to a discipline. It can be predicted that this process will continue and the era of soma-esthetics has just begun.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Herder on Sculpture: Touching, Tactility and Body
    Gao Yanping
    2019, 39 (5):  43-51. 
    Abstract ( 362 )   PDF (1318KB) ( 264 )  

    This article aims to elucidate Herder's main theory on sculpture that sculpture is a tactile art, and also tries to construct Herder's implicit theory on "tactility". It argues that Herder's haptic quality is much embodied, and could be divides into two categories, the emphatic and the abstract, the thickly embodied and the thinly embodied. Towards the end this article will demonstrate that the domination of the former nevertheless leads to Herder's partial blindness on the tactility of different sculptures.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Modern and Contemporary Literary Theory
    Essential Differences between the Late Qing and the May Fourth Written Vernacular Chinese
    Gao Yu
    2019, 39 (5):  52-62. 
    Abstract ( 411 )   PDF (1339KB) ( 191 )  

    Dedicated to enlightenment, the late Qing movement of written vernacular Chinese spread both old and new ideas, whereas the May Fourth movement of written vernacular Chinese was an intellectual revolution. Not only did they refuse old ideas, May Fourth literati radically criticized traditional Chinese culture and initiated the modernization of China on both intellectual and social levels. Essentially, the written vernacular Chinese of the late Qing dynasty is a language of instrumentality, whereas that of the May Fourth is a language of thought. The former, mainly including colloquialism and slangs, was an auxiliary language of classical Chinese and unable to articulate ideas as an independent writing system, while the latter, aiming to replace classical Chinese from the outset, eventually developed into a self-sufficient language system known as modern Chinese. This process explains the formation of China's cultural modernity on the linguistic level.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Humanistic Discourse and Knowledge Production of Literary Theory in the Early Years of the New Era
    Lu Yaming
    2019, 39 (5):  63-71. 
    Abstract ( 137 )   PDF (1735KB) ( 138 )  

    Humanistic discourse is not inherently associated with the production of literary theory at its inception, but has become part of the production of literary theory knowledge and participated in the construction of the literary theory knowledge system in a specific way at a particular moment, humanistic discourse as a literary theory should be examined not only in relation to specific international and domestic historical contexts and actual social factors but also from the perspective of the formative process of the literary theory field in the new era. Humanistic literary theory was of great significance in the initial stage of the formation of literary theory field in the New Era, and lay the foundation for subsequent literary theory forms such as aesthetic-emotional literary theory as well as new concepts, ideas and methods.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Chinese Medicine, Western Medicine, and Patients: Writings on Infectious Disease during the Debate between Chinese and Western Medicine
    Deng Xiaoyan
    2019, 39 (5):  72-82. 
    Abstract ( 231 )   PDF (1724KB) ( 65 )  

    Modern epidemiology led to a comprehensive change in social concepts. As a result, the fear of bacteria became a psychological basis of social mobilization in modern countries. In China, the fear of bacteria and the fear of Western forces were ingeniously combined, thus becoming the emotional motivation for New Culture intellectuals who fervently criticized traditional Chinese medicine under the slogan of scientism. In the context of the debate between Chinese and Western medicine, this article focuses on the writings of infectious diseases in modern Chinese literature. By analyzing the texts and events related to Chen Dabei, Sun Fuyuan, Lu Xun, Ye Shengtao, Wang Luyan, and Xu Qinwen, this article reveals the interstice in modern Chinese literature created by the subtle tension between enlightenment and scientism, and also demonstrates the situation of traditional Chinese medicine in the modern period, in order to provide a new case for reflecting on modern Chinese literature from the perspective of traditional knowledge.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Cunning Apparatus and the Pain of Modern Literature: A Parallactic Reading of Kojin Karatani's Literary Theory
    Han Shangrong
    2019, 39 (5):  83-91. 
    Abstract ( 292 )   PDF (1385KB) ( 153 )  

    Since Kojin Karatani's Origins of Modern Japanese Literature was published, it has been regarded as an example of modern criticism based on rationalism. Considering Karatani's theoretical constructions at that time and his entire academic career, a hidden concept of parallax can be found, and the apparatus that exists in modern Japanese literature, as Karatani sees it, results from the lack of this parallax. In contrast to modern literature's emphasis on self-consciousness, the apparatus excludes self-consciousness and engenders a closed field by means of this exclusion. Therefore, arguments on modern literature, such as depth and plot, remain inside the apparatus; not only do they fail to disintegrate the apparatus, they reinforce and activate it instead. Overall, parallax unveils the symptomatic nature of the concepts such as "origin", "end," and "modern literature" and uncovers the historicity and constructiveness of literary conception. This article attempts to unravel the Karatanian apparatus through the lens of parallax. Taking "origin" and "end" as interactive counterparts in the same field, it revisits the formation and functions of the apparatus on the epistemological level. The conclusion, however, is that the involvement of parallax offers an opportunity to get free from the apparatus and undermine it from the outside.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Classical Literary Theory and Criticism
    The Image Consciousness in Literary Criticism of Fu in Ancient China
    Xu Jie
    2019, 39 (5):  92-101. 
    Abstract ( 150 )   PDF (1772KB) ( 107 )  

    Image consciousness in literary criticism in ancient China is most prominent in the criticism of Fu (Rhapsody), which can be seen from Liu Xie's "describing objects as they appear" in "Interpreting the Genre Rhapsody" (501-2 A.D.) to Zhu Guangqian's comment that "Rhapsody is akin to pictures" in On Poetry (1943). The imagist representation in the criticism tradition involves a way of "picturely" thinking developed from the fusion of verbal and pictorial horizons, with theoretical basis in rhapsody's linguistic characteristic of graphic description and the aesthetic configuration on objects and images. The image-representing way of thinking and the graphic criticism of commenting rhapsody through images in rhapsody study may be taken to as a case study of the relationship between text and image, and this study may not only deepen the understanding of rhapsody and images, but also provide a new perspective for the study of Chinese literary theory.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    The Idea about Writing to "Convery the Truth" of the Aixuan School in the Southern Song Period and Its Cultural Significance
    Zheng Tianxi
    2019, 39 (5):  102-109. 
    Abstract ( 198 )   PDF (1777KB) ( 165 )  

    The four generations of the epigones of the Aixuan School in the Southern Song dynasty laid equal emphases on wen and dao, the artistic and ideological aspects of literature. The importance of human nature rose to prominence in this process, and finally obtained the same position as the ideological requirement for writing to "convey the truth". The increasing focus on the nature of literature was a projection of the secularization of Neo-Confucianism from the Southern Song period. Despite the Neo-Confucian repression of literature, it was a special phenomenon that the Aixuan School insisted on its belief in literature and continued its creative and critical practices in poetry and essays. This article analyzes the Aixuan School's perceptions of wen and dao, and examines the changes in these perceptions over time, thus exploring its cultural significance in the historical context of the Southern Song dynasty.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Function Words through the Critical Lens of Traditional Stylistics and Its Later Interpretations in the Early Modern Era
    Chang Fangzhou
    2019, 39 (5):  110-120. 
    Abstract ( 167 )   PDF (1343KB) ( 131 )  

    Essayists of the Tang and Song dynasties consciously celebrated the rhetorical effect of function words, which made function words an important subject in traditional stylistics. During the Qing dynasty, discussions on function words had two voices. In contrast to the school of philology's linguistic approach, the school of rhetoric focused on the style of writing to illuminate the rhetorical significance of function words. In the early modern era, Chinese scholars familiarized themselves with the categorization of Western learning and made attempts to reveal the characteristics of classical prose from a holistic perspective. By looking at function words' rhetorical effect in the context of grammatical analysis, they considered function words to be not only an essential to the genre of prose but also a concrete representation of traditional stylistics.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    The Dissolution of Dualism and the Reflective Nature of the "Contestation between the Tang and the Song Poetry" in the Qing Dynasty
    Tang Yunyun
    2019, 39 (5):  121-131. 
    Abstract ( 233 )   PDF (1733KB) ( 561 )  

    The "contestation between the Tang and the Song poetry" in the Qing dynasty is commonly viewed dualistically as a rivalry between the pro-Tang poetry group and the pro-Song poetry group. However, the said contestation was not an dispute over learning from the Tang poetry or the Song poetry in poetry writing practice, because their theoretical footings of the two groups do not cover the same ground to form a dualist opposition. At the core of the contestation are the dispute over the value of the Song poetry, and the discussions of traditional poetical concepts such as "poetry expressing ideals," temperament of decency, style differentiation, and so forth, and therefore the above-said contestation could be rephrased as the dispute  over the core concepts of traditional poetics. The contestation was concluded from two theoretical paths which explored the continuity of the Tang poetry and invalidated the rationality of the opposition between the Tang and the Song poetry, and from this perspective it can be seen that the contestation had a reflective nature. In this way, the intensions and extensions of the "contestation between the Tang poetry and the Song poetry" can be clarified.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    On the Theoretical Construction of the Characteristics of Tongguang Style Poetry by Tongguang Style Poets
    Zhang Xiaowei
    2019, 39 (5):  132-143. 
    Abstract ( 249 )   PDF (1796KB) ( 159 )  

    The Tongguang Style poetry, which had its origins in the Song School poetry during the reigns of Emperor Daoguang and Xianfeng (1821-1861), represented a profound innovative force within traditional poetry in both theory and creation. Tongguang Style poets also had systematically theoretical construction of the characteristics of their creation. They rebelled against the "orthodox form" in previous poetry and opposed Zhang Zhidong's theory of "qingqie" (explicit), by raising a set of binaries such as "qingqie" and "pise" (recondite), as well as "guangyi" (transparent) and "jianshen" (difficult). Zheng Xiaoxu also said that in modern society, "everything changes with disturbance outside and complicated moods boiling inside". Therefore, poets should write poems that "are out of musicality" and "without expectations for accuracy". They also traced their own style of poetry back to Ya (Court Hymns) poetry through positioning Ya antithetically against Feng (Airs of the States) by referring to The Book of Songs. The theory of "scholarly poetry" was completed by Shen Zengzhi through his poetry criticism that centered on "yi" (idea), "bi" (writing), and "se" (material), and criticism of metaphysical poetry during the Eastern Jin dynasty (317-420), with the Zheng Xiaoxu's words quoted above as its historical reason. A series of adjectives used by the Tongguang Style poets in their comments reflected this new change in poetics on aesthetic intuition. In many ways, the poetics of Tongguang Style poets coincided with T. S. Eliot's, the eminent Western modernist poet born later, because they both came to a similar turning point in the history of poetry of their own.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Western Literary Theory and Criticism
    "The Dark-houred Clock": Embodiment and Abstraction in Celan's Poetry
    Dorit Lemberger
    2019, 39 (5):  144-160. 
    Abstract ( 187 )   PDF (1335KB) ( 86 )  

    Celan's poetry is replete with metaphors that function in various ways. This article looks at two opposed functions of metaphor there: embodiment and abstraction. They rest on the fact that most cognitive processes occur unconsciously, leaving us with only a limited ability to understand their connections to metaphors. This makes it difficult to understand how a metaphor bridges between faraway and even opposed semantic fields. The dual metaphorical functions will be studied as used in three themes of Celan's language: (1) language as expression and as concealment, (2) interaction with the Other as a key to self-constitution, and (3) the drawing of the boundary between life and death. Because these themes make it difficult to understand the function of embodiment in Celan's poetry, a systematic integration of common ideas in cognitive linguistics with Wittgensteinian concepts will be suggested with the aim of showing how Celan's poetic language deals with these complexities.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Western Literary Theory and Studies in Aesthetics
    Why Is K. A Land Surveyor?
    Zeng Yanbing
    2019, 39 (5):  161-169. 
    Abstract ( 261 )   PDF (1745KB) ( 178 )  

    In Franz Kafka's novel The Castle, the protagonist K. claims that he is a land surveyor by profession. However, K. has no land to survey, which undermines the certainty of K.'s profession. Why, then, did Kafka choose this ancient profession for his protagonist? The uncertainty of K.'s identity, the paper claims, implies that K. is in essence an explorer of existence. Thus, Kafka was a pioneer of existentialist writers. Giorgio Agamben argues that the protagonist K. gets the name from kardo, an old instrument for land surveying. The land surveyor's work is to establish and to break boundaries — not only those between lands, but also those between men, between man and deities, and between men and their selves. Man's existence lies forever between boundary establishment and abolishment.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Western Literary Theory and Criticism
    On Rancière's Concept of Modern Fiction
    Cao Danhong
    2019, 39 (5):  170-177. 
    Abstract ( 213 )   PDF (1303KB) ( 117 )  

    Jacques Rancière has a long-standing interest in fictional issues. In recent years, he has published several monographs, in which he ponders the nature of modern fiction and presented unique insights. Rancière's concept of modern fiction is based on the critique of the traditional fictional rationality pioneered by Aristotle and the inheritance of scholars and writers such as Schiller, Keats, Flaubert, Woolf, Auerbach. It points out that the core of modern fiction is no longer the imitation of an organic whole action, but rather the manifestation of juxtaposed sensible micro-events. Changes in content lead to changes in the form of modern fiction. Description, which was marginalized in traditional fiction, has gained equal status to or even more important status than narrative, fundamentally changing the texture of modern fiction. A study of Rancière's concept of modern fiction helps further understand his aesthetics and politics of literature, and also provides a novel perspective for rethinking modern fictional writing.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Classical Literary Theory and Criticism
    The Significance of "Sense of Beauty" in Eighteenth-century British Aesthetics
    Li Jialian, Lei Yunfeng
    2019, 39 (5):  178-186. 
    Abstract ( 211 )   PDF (3529KB) ( 353 )  

    Centering on "sense of beauty," the inner sense theory developed by Shaftesbury and Hutcheson is highly significant to eighteenth-century British aesthetics. However, due to linguistic and cultural differences, these two concepts have not been well received by the Chinese intelligentsia. By focusing on "sense of beauty," this paper aims to delineate the concept's development in eighteenth-century British aesthetics and evaluate its academic significance in the history of Western aesthetics, with the purpose of supporting the theoretical construction of contemporary Chinese aesthetics.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    Western Literary Theory and Criticism
    An Access to Europe's "Límpensé": François Jullien's Conceptualization of Classical Chinese Aesthetics
    Han Zhenhua
    2019, 39 (5):  187-197. 
    Abstract ( 309 )   PDF (1359KB) ( 1561 )  

    The classical Chinese aesthetics that French sinologist François Jullien tries to construct is centered on such notions as plain (la fadeur), non-objet, désontologie, and l'immanence. In so doing, Jullien aims to give Europe an access to  "l'impensé" via Chinese aesthetics. However, his endeavour presents itself to be more like a derivative of post-structuralist  theories of Foucault and Deleuze and an invention than a reliable representation of China. On the fundamental level, Jullien's views of Chinese thought follows those of Hegel and Max Weber. Although he tries to reexamine Hegel's negative comments on China, his seemingly exquisite discussions fail to rectify the stereotyical notion of European Sinology. Meanwhile, Jullien values the Heideggerian concept of "the undifferentiated basis prior to the realization of form," which has a non-interventional and non-political import. Despite this philosophical ambition, Jullien fails to reach out to reflecting contemporary socio-political problems and therefore his aesthetic construction entails questions in terms of its relevance to current politics.

    Related Articles | Metrics
    "If There Is No God, Nothing Is Permitted at All": Žižek on Cyberspace
    Dai Yuchen
    2019, 39 (5):  198-208. 
    Abstract ( 658 )   PDF (1773KB) ( 193 )  

    Cyberspace and virtual reality are two topical concepts in new media studies. Among diverse discourses, Slavoj Žižek's critique of cyberspace is highly prominent. In constrast to the mainstream technological determinism, Žižek argues that the rise of cyberspace initiates an era characterized by "the retreat of big Other," and without the Other that functions as the Master to safeguard the norm for individual's actions. This ressesion of Master's function means, as Žižek claims in light of Lacanian psychoanalysis, that the subject will not be informed of what should be desired, and the subject is thus deprived of the access to effective choices. The subject now bears the "burden of choice" once born by the Other and falls into grip of what Lacan describes as "If there is no God, nothing is permitted at all."

    Related Articles | Metrics
    "Ecological Justice": Two Kinds of Metaphysical Defense
    Zhao Qing
    2019, 39 (5):  209-217. 
    Abstract ( 238 )   PDF (1319KB) ( 73 )  

    This article aims to undertake an epistemological discussion of ecological justice with de-subjectivity as its core theme from both the perspectives of Adorno's ecological theology and Shi Tao's proposition of "spokesman for shan-shui". The former argues that the negative dialectics holds the possibility of approaching nature itself, and the latter advocates the harmony of heaven and human. Specifically, Adorno elevated the status of nature in the realm of human beings created by God, whereby nature acquires divinity and subjectivity is suppressed. In a different yet compatible way, by conceptualizing the harmony between heaven and human for the exclusivity of subjectivity, Shi Tao rejected the disharmony between nature and human beings. The article concludes that, different as they are in theorization, both are useful not only to the legitimization of ecological justice, but, as well, in defense of the epistemology.

    Related Articles | Metrics