欢迎访问《文艺理论研究》,

文艺理论研究 ›› 2018, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (1): 148-160.

• 专题:近现代戏曲学术史研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

民国时期戏曲史著中的古代戏曲学经典议题

黄静枫   

  1. 上海戏剧学院戏剧与影视学博士后流动站
  • 出版日期:2018-01-25 发布日期:2018-10-19
  • 作者简介:黄静枫,文学博士,上海戏剧学院戏剧与影视学博士后流动站师资博士后。主要从事戏曲理论与戏曲史学史研究。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科项目“民国传奇杂剧史论”[项目编号:15BZW121];第62批中国博士后科学基金面上资助项目“‘十七年’时期戏曲史学研究”[项目编号:2017M621518]阶段性成果

The Classical Propositions of Ancient Opera Studies in the Historiography of Opera in the Period of the Republic of China

Huang Jingfeng   

  1. Theatre and Film Studies Mobile Research Station in Shanghai Theatre Academy
  • Online:2018-01-25 Published:2018-10-19
  • About author:Huang Jingfeng, Ph.D., Postdoctoral Fellow of Theatre and Film Studies Mobile Research Station in Shanghai Theatre Academy. His research focuses on Classical Chinese Drama Theory and Historical Science of Traditional Chinese Opera.
  • Supported by:
    the National Social Science Fund of China (15BZW121) , and the 62nd batch of General Financial Grant from the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2017M621518) 

摘要: 20世纪上半叶戏曲史家在其戏曲史书写中继续讨论古代戏曲学经典议题。他们借助议题讨论开展历史评论,并将其“熨帖”地安置在历史框架中,使之成为史述的一部分。进入这一时期戏曲史著的经典议题有四类:分类议题、比较议题、寻因议题、溯本议题。参与历史讲述的议题讨论不仅具有史纂层面的意义,还拥有戏曲学史层面的双重“意味”。一方面,史家在继续讨论前,会对古人“跨时空”的论争进行梳理,这实际是一项回顾古代戏曲学的工作;另一方面,史家与古人在论述同一议题时视角与观点的差异,反映出戏曲史学开始步入逻辑实证的时代。这本身是考察转型期学术特征的直接史料。

关键词: 古代戏曲学, 经典议题, 戏曲史纂, 书写策略, 学术转型

Abstract: Chinese opera historians in the first half of the 20 th century continued the discussion of the classical propositions of ancient opera studies in their historiography of traditional Chinese opera. They conducted historical criticism through reconsidering the classical propositions and appropriately placed them in the historical context, thus making it a part of historical narrative. There are four categories of classical propositions that entered into the historical studies in this period: classification, comparison, revelation of causes, story prototype tracing. The reconsideration of classical propositions has not only historiographical value, but also twofold significance at the level of opera history. On the one hand, historians sorted out ancient people's "trans-time-andspace" debates before reopening the discussion, which are actually reviews of ancient studies of opera. On the other hand, the differences in perspectives and viewpoints between modern historians and ancient people reflect that the studies of opera history have entered into an era of logical positivism.

Key words: ancient opera studies, classical propositions, historiography of opera, writing strategy, academic transformation