后现代主义语境中的知识重构与学术转向——当代文学“历史化”的谱系考察与视阈拓展

文艺理论研究 ›› 2016, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (4): 84-93.

• 专题：后现代主义与文学研究 • 上一篇下一篇

后现代主义语境中的知识重构与学术转向——当代文学“历史化”的谱系考察与视阈拓展

吴秀明

浙江大学中文系

出版日期:2016-07-25 发布日期:2017-09-29
作者简介:吴秀明，浙江大学中文系教授，博士生导师，主要从事中国现当代文学研究。
基金资助:
本文为国家社科基金2015年重点项目“当代文学研究的‘历史化’及其主要路径与方法”[项目编号：15AZW009]阶段性成果。

Knowledge Reconstruction and Academic Reorientation in Postmodernist Context: A Genealogical Study and the Expansion of its Horizon of the Historicization of Contemporary Literary Studies

Wu Xiuming

the Department of Chinese Literature, Zhejiang University

Online:2016-07-25 Published:2017-09-29
About author:Wu Xiuming is a Professor in the Department of Chinese Literature, Zhejiang University, with research focus on Chinese contemporary literature.

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 20世纪90年代以来，在全球化和后现代主义影响下，当代文学领域出现了由思想阐释走向知识重构的重要转向，它在推进学科建设的同时，也为当代文学研究的“历史化”提供了潜在背景和理论支撑。目前，这一“转向”还在进行之中，加之“历史化”概念本身充满歧义，因此显得颇为复杂。但它不同于此前的“重写文学史”等思潮，其具体研究和推演，不仅在外源性上受到詹姆逊等西方马克思主义理论的影响，而且在内源性上与中国汉宋两学诠释系统具有血脉的关联；从海峡两岸四地的特殊历史现状来看，它还有一个“文学中国”问题。而内源性思想和“文学中国”问题，在当下“历史化”中往往有意无意地被忽略了，所以有必要引起重视。

关键词: 历史化, 概念辨析, 研究现状, 源流梳理, 文学中国

Abstract: Since the 1990s, in the context of globalization and postmodernism, a reorientation is emerging in contemporary literary studies from intellectual interpretation to knowledge reconstruction. The reorientation both promotes contemporary literary studies as a discipline and helps to contextualize and theoretically endorse the historicization of the studies. The reorientation is an emerging phenomenon, which is further complicated by the ambiguity of the concept of "historicization." Unlike the earlier endeavor of "rewriting of literary history," this reorientation, in terms of its scope of research and its conceptual evolution, is both influenced externally by Western Marxist theories through such theorists as Fredric Jameson and internally stimulated by the interpretive systems of the textual study developed in the Han dynasty and the neo-Confucianism developed in the Song Dynasty. Given the historical context of the Greater China, the reorientation is also complicated by the issue of "Literary China," and the interaction between the internal stimulation and the issue of Literary China in the process of the "historicization" deserves more attention than the current neglect.

Key words: historicization, concept definition, current research, genealogy, Literary China

吴秀明. 后现代主义语境中的知识重构与学术转向——当代文学“历史化”的谱系考察与视阈拓展[J]. 文艺理论研究, 2016, 36(4): 84-93.

Wu Xiuming. Knowledge Reconstruction and Academic Reorientation in Postmodernist Context: A Genealogical Study and the Expansion of its Horizon of the Historicization of Contemporary Literary Studies[J]. Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art, 2016, 36(4): 84-93.

陈晓明:《中国当代文学主潮》。北京:北京大学出版社,2009年。[Chen,Xiaoming.Main Currents of Chinese Contemporary Literature.Beijing:Peking University Press,2009.]
——:“个人记忆与历史的客观化”,《当代作家评论》3(2002):113—22。[——."Individual's Memory and the Objectification of History."Contemporary Writers Review 3(2002):113-22.]
陈寅恪:《金明馆丛稿二编》。上海:上海古籍出版社,1980年。[Chen,Yingque.The Second Volume of Essays from Jinming Guan.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House,1980.]
程光炜:“总序”,《当代文学的“历史化”》。北京:北京大学出版社,2011年。第2页。[Cheng,Guangwei."General Preface."The Historization of Contemporary Literature.Beijing:Peking University Press,2011.2.]
程光炜魏华莹:“在‘当代'与‘历史'之间——程光炜教授访谈”,《学术月刊》7(2013):171—76。[Cheng,Guangwei&Wei Huaying."Between the Contemporary and the Historical:Interview with Pro.Cheng Guangwei."Academic Monthly 7(2013):171-76.]
龚鹏程:《有文化的文学课》。北京:中华书局,2015年。[Gong,Pengcheng.Cultured Literature Classes.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2015.]
黑格尔:《小逻辑》。北京:商务印书馆,1980年。[Hegel.Lesser Logic.Beijing:The Commercial Press,1980.]
洪子诚:“前言”,《中国当代文学史》。北京:北京大学出版社,1999年。第5页。[Hong,Zicheng."Preface."A History of Contemporary Literature.Beijing:Peking University Press,1999.5.]
黄修己:《中国新文学史编纂史》。北京:北京大学出版社,1995年。[Huang,Xiuji.The Compiling History of the History of Chinese New Literature.Beijing:Peking University Press,1995.]
弗雷德里克·詹姆逊:《政治无意识》。北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999年。[Jameson,Fredric.The Political Unconscious.Beijing:China Social Sciences Press,1999.]
——:《晚期资本主义的文化逻辑》。北京:三联书店,牛津大学出版社,1997年。[——.The Cultural Logic of the Late Capitalism.Beijing:SDX Joint Publishing Company,1997.]
米兰·昆德拉:《被背叛的遗嘱》,孟湄译。上海:上海人民出版社,1995年。[Kundera,Milan.Testaments Betrayed.Trans.Meng,Mei.Shanghai:Shanghai People's Publishing House,1995.]
李美皆:“‘晚年丁玲'与青年作家”,《文学报)2015年9月10日:020。Li,Meijie."Late-Year Ding Ling and Young Writers."Literature Newspaper.10 Sep.2015:020.]
孟繁华程光炜:《中国当代文学发展史》(修订本)。北京:北京大学出版社,2011年。[Meng,Fanhua and Cheng Guangwei.History of the Development of Contemporary Literature.Beijing:Peking University Press,2011.]
史书美:“反离散:华语语系作为文化生产的场域”,《华文文学》6(2011):5—14。[Shih,Shumei."Against Diaspora:Sinophone as the Field of Cultural Production."Literatures in Chinese 6(2011):5-14.]
施蛰存:“当代事,不成‘史'”,《文汇报》1985年12月2日:003。[Shi,Zhecun."Contemporary Matters Cannot Become History."Wenhui Bao.2 Dec.1985:003.]
唐弢:“当代文学不宜写史”,《文汇报》1985年10月29日:004。[Tang,Tao."Contemporary Literature Should Not Be Written into History."Wenhui Boo.29 Oct.1985:004.]
王尧:“‘关联研究'与当代文学史论述”,《当代作家评论》5(2009):4—13。[Wang,Yao."Association Study and the Discourse of the History of Contemporary Literature."Contemporary Writers Review 5(2009):4-13.]
解志熙:“‘古典化'与‘平常心'——关于中国现代文学研究的若干断想”,《中国现代文学研究丛刊》1(1997):88—90。[Xie,Zhixi."Canonization and the Composed State of Mind:Thoughts on Chinese Modern Literature Studies."Modem Chinese Literature Studies 1(1997):88-90.]
杨庆祥:“文学、历史和方法——程光炜访谈录”,程光炜:《当代文学的“历史化”》。北京:北京大学出版社,2011年。第16、226、230、231页。[Yang,Qingxiang."Literature,History and Method:An Interview with Cheng Guangwei."General Preface.By Cheng,Guangwei.Beijing:Peking University Press,2011:16,226,230,231.]
杨义:“20世纪交学全史论纲(中)”,《海南师范大学学报》7(2015):14。[Yang,Yi."A Treatise on the 2.0th Century Literary History,PartⅡ."Journal of Hainan Normal University7(2015):14.]
张清华:“在历史化与当代性之间——关于当代文学研究与批评状况的思考”,《文艺研究》12(2009):11—13。[Zhang,Qinghua."Between Histori:zation and Contempqrariness:Thoughts on the Current Situation of Contemporary Literature Research and Criticism."Literature&Art Studies 12(2009):11-13.]
(1)参见颜水生:“论当代‘历史化'思潮及其反思”,《南方文坛》2(2011):21。
(2)同上。
(3)参见泓峻:“‘去历史化'写作的负面影响”,《文艺报》2015年2月4日:002;李德南:“从去历史化、非历史化到重新历史化——新世纪小说叙事的实践与想象”,《新文学评论》4(2012):100—07。
(4)引自杨晓帆、虞金星:“当代文学研究的‘历史化'研讨会纪要”,《文艺争鸣》1(2010):79—90。
(5)王德威对“华语语系文学”作了较多的辨析,参见王德威:“华语语系文学:边界想像与越界建构”,《中山大学学报》5(2006):1—4;“‘根'的政治,‘势'的诗学——华语论述与中国文学”,《扬子江评论》1(2014):5—13;等。

后现代主义语境中的知识重构与学术转向——当代文学“历史化”的谱系考察与视阈拓展

Knowledge Reconstruction and Academic Reorientation in Postmodernist Context: A Genealogical Study and the Expansion of its Horizon of the Historicization of Contemporary Literary Studies

PDF (PC)

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

相关文章 1

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价