审美文论的发生、发展及其流变——一个知识谱系学的考察

文艺理论研究 ›› 2016, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (4): 15-26.

• 会议专题：“文艺学学科反思的回顾与前瞻” • 上一篇下一篇

审美文论的发生、发展及其流变——一个知识谱系学的考察

邢建昌，张皓

河北师范大学

出版日期:2016-07-25 发布日期:2017-09-29
作者简介:邢建昌，河北师范大学文学院教授、文学博士，主要从事基础文艺理论、文艺美学和当代文化批评研究。张皓，河北师范大学文艺学专业2009届硕士研究生。
基金资助:
本文系作者主持的教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目《20世纪80年以来代文学理论的知识生产及其相关问题[项目编号：14JJD750002]以及李春青主持的国家社科基金重点项目《新时期文艺理论与批评建设及关联因素研究》[项目编号：12AZD013]的阶段成果。

The Origin and Evolvement of Aesthetic Poetics from the Perspective of Genealogy

Xing Jianchang, Zhang Hao

Hebei Normal University (Shijiazhuang 050024, China)

Online:2016-07-25 Published:2017-09-29
About author:Xing Jianchang, Ph.D., is a professor at Hebei Normal University (Shijiazhuang 050024, China). His major research areas cover aesthetics, literature and art aesthetics, basic literary theories and contemporary cultural criticism. Zhang Hao is a Master candidate in literature and art at Hebei Normal University.

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 本文是对20世纪80年代以来审美文论的发生、发展及其流变的一个知识谱系学的考察。审美文论的一个前奏、一个序曲，是肇始于20世纪50、60年代，至70年代末再掀论争的形象思维的讨论。形象思维讨论的意义，在于确立了文学艺术不同于概念认识的形象特征。从形象认识说到情感说，铺平了通向文学审美本质说的道路。对于审美的感召、教育、拯救、解放功能的强调，说明审美文论是一种带有强烈功利诉求的文论范式。审美文论的价值系统在进入90年代后表现出了与时代氛围的龃龉，不能有效言说新的文化现实。审美文论的发生、发展及其流变说明：任何一种本质论都不过是在特定历史境遇中对文学意义的觉解。即使在某个时段内占据主导性的本质论，最终都会被取代，被超越。研究文学是为了体悟文学的丰富性、复杂性及其内在的生命意义，而不是给它找一个独一的本质。

关键词: 形象思维, 审美文论, 功利话语, 反本质主义

Abstract: This article is a genealogical investigation of the origin and evolvement of aesthetic poetics in China since the 1980s. Its prelude originated from the "imagistic thinking Debate" in the 1950s and 1960s, which was revived at the end of the 1970s. The outcome of this debate was a common recognition that the image, rather than concepts, features literature and art. The evolvement from image epistemology to affectionism paved the way to an aestheticism-based theory. However, the emphasis on the functions of aestheticism to appeal, to educate, to save, and to liberate indicates that the aesthetic poetics was a utilitarian literary paradigm. Out of key with the time in the 1990s, the value system of aestheticism fell short of addressing the new cultural reality. The origin, development, and evolvement of this aesthetic poetics have proved that any essentialist poetics is just an interpretation of literature under certain circumstances. Though dominant in one period, it will be replaced and surpassed. The purpose of literary study is to comprehend literature's richness, intricacy, and significance to life, rather than attaching to it an essence.

Key words: image thinking, aesthetic poetics, utilitarian discourse, anti-essentialism

邢建昌, 张皓. 审美文论的发生、发展及其流变——一个知识谱系学的考察[J]. 文艺理论研究, 2016, 36(4): 15-26.

Xing Jianchang, Zhang Hao. The Origin and Evolvement of Aesthetic Poetics from the Perspective of Genealogy[J]. Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art, 2016, 36(4): 15-26.

邓友梅:“文艺职能之我见——在一次座谈会上的发言”,《上海文学》1(1980):81—83。[Deng,Youmei."My Opinion on the Function of Literature and Art:a Talk on a Forum."Shanghai Literature 1(1980):81-83.]
冯小刚王朔等:《编辑部的故事·精彩对白欣赏》。北京:中国广播电视出版社,1992年。[Feng,Xiaogang,and Wang Shuo,et al.Stories from the Editorial Board:those Wonderful Dialogues.Beijing:China Radio&Television Publishing House,1992.]
韩凌舒炜光:“形象思维问题新探”,《社会科学战线》2(1978):179—89。[Han,Ling,and Shu Weiguang."A New Exploration on Image Thinking."Social Science Front 2(1978):179-89.]
李泽厚:“形象思维续谈”,《学术研究》1(1978):94—102。[Li,Zehou."A Continued Discussion on Image Thinking."Academic Studies 1(1978):94-102.]
刘再复:“论文艺批评的美学标准”,《中国社会科学》6(1980):173—98。[Liu,Zaifu."On the Aesthetic Standards of Literary Criticism."Social Sciences in China 6(1980):173-98.]
鲁枢元:“文学,美的领域——兼论文学艺术家的‘感情积累'”,《上海文学》6(1981):43—49。[Lu,Shuyuan."Literature,a Field of Beauty,with a Mentioning of Literary Men's Emotional Accumulation."Shanghai Literature 6(1981):43-49.]
钱中文:“文学理论现代性问题——生成中的现代审美意识与文学理论”,《文学理论:走向交往对话的时代》。北京:北京大学出版社,1999年。第279—336页。[Qian,Zhongwen."The Modernity of Literary Theories:the Growing Modern Aesthetic Consciousness and Literary Theories."Literary Theories:Towards an Age of Communication Dialogue.Beijing:Peking University Press,1999.279-336.]
邱明正:“一个不精确的口号——评‘文艺是阶级斗争的工具'说”,《上海文学》8(1979):79—82。[Qiu,Mingzheng."An Inaccurate Slogan:a Criticism on'Literature and Art Are Tools for Class Struggle'."Shanghai Literature 8(1979):79-82.]
陶东风主编:《文学理论基本问题》。北京:北京大学出版社,2008年。[Tao,Dongfeng,ed.Basic Issues in Literary Theories.Beijing:Peking University Press,2008.]
——:“反思社会学视野中的文艺学知识建构”,《文学评论》5(2007):12—18。[——."The Knowledge Construction in Literature and Art Studies from a Perspective of Reflective Sociology."Literature Review 5(2007):12-18.]
童庆炳:“关于文学特征问题的思考”,《北京师范大学学报》6(1981):54—59。[Tong,Qingbing."A Reflection on the Characteristics of Literature."Journal of Beijing Normal University 6(1981):54-59.]
——:《文学活动的审美维度》。北京:高等教育出版社,2001年。[——.The Aesthetic Dimension of Literary Activities.Beijing:Higher Education Press,2001.]
——:“文艺学边界三题”,《文学评论》6(2004):54—59。[——."Three Issues Concerning the Boundaries of Literature and Art Studies."Literature Review 6(2004):54-59.]
王家新孙文波编:《中国诗歌九十年代备忘录》。北京:人民文学出版社,2000年。[Wang,Jiaxin,and Sun Wenbo,ed.A Memorandom on Chinese Poetry in 1990s.Beijing:People's Literature Publishing House,2000.]
王元骧:“情感——文学艺术的基本特性”,《文学评论》5(1983):91—102。[Wang,Yuanxiang."Affection:the Basic Characteristic of Literature and Art."Literature Review 5(1983):91-102.]
王岳川尚水编:《后现代主义文化与美学》。北京:北京大学出版社,1992年。[Wang,Yuechuan,and Shang Shui,ed.Postmodernist Culture and Aesthetics.Beijing:Peking University Press,1992.]
夏中义:“文学是非纯认识性的精神活动”,《文艺理论研究》3(1982):141—43。[Xia,Zhongyi."Literature:a Spiritual Activity without Being Entirely Epistemological."Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art 3(1982):141-43.]
邢建昌:“形象思维与文学本质特征的探索”,《文艺理论研究》6(2011):2—12。[Xing,Jianchang."An Exploration of Image Thinking and Literary Essence."Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art 6(2011):2-12.]
杨振铎:“关于文艺本质的几个问题——兼与夏中义同志商榷”,《文艺理论研究》1(1983):101—05。[Yang,Zhenduo."Several Issues on Literary Essence,with a Discussion with Mr.Xia Zhongyi."Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art 1(1983):101-05.]
张景超:“一种误读:后现代对新写实”,《文艺评论》6(1993):34—41。[Zhang,Jingchao."A Type of Misreading:Postmodernism vs.Neorealism."Literature and Art Criticism 6(1993):34-41.]
周来祥:“审美情感与艺术本质”,《文史哲》3(1981):3—8。[Zhou,Laixiang."Aesthetic Feelings and the Essence of Art."Journal of Literature,History and Philosophy 3(1981):3-8.]

[1]	曹谦. “形象思维”再考察——以朱光潜和李泽厚形象思维论为中心 [J]. 文艺理论研究, 2015, 35(6): 36-44.
[2]	何燕李. 丛林深处绞缠的反本质主义与本质主义群像——盖茨的非裔文学理论研究 [J]. 文艺理论研究, 2013, 33(4): 203-210.
[3]	王伟. 文学性、反本质主义及空间转向 [J]. 文艺理论研究, 2012, 32(5): 139-144.

审美文论的发生、发展及其流变——一个知识谱系学的考察

The Origin and Evolvement of Aesthetic Poetics from the Perspective of Genealogy

PDF (PC)

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

相关文章 3

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价