包世臣:《艺舟双楫》。北京:北京市中国书店,1983年。[Bao,Shichen.Double Oars for the Boat of Arts.Beijing:Chinese Publishing House,1983.] 曹济平:“唐圭璋先生对词学的贡献”,《文学遗产》2(1992):95-100。[Cao,Jiping.“Tang Guizhang's Contribution to Ci-Poetry Theory.”Literary Heritage 2(1992):95-100.] 蔡嵩云:“柯亭词论”,《词话丛编》第5册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Cai,Songyun.“Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Keting Studio.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.5.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 陈匪石:“宋词赏心录跋”,《词话丛编补编》第5册,葛渭君编。北京:中华书局,2013年。[Chen,Feishi.“Postscript to the Commentary Annotations to Appreciation of Song-Dynasty Ci-Poems.”Supplement to the Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.5.Ed.Ge Weijun.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2013.] ---:《宋词举》。南京:金陵书画社,1983年。[---.Examples of Song-Dyansty Ci-Poems.Nanjing:Jinling Calligraphy and Painting Publishing House,1983.] 陈良玉:“随山馆词稿序”,《清词序跋汇编》第3册,冯乾编校。南京:凤凰出版社,2013年。[Chen,Liangyu.“Introductory Essay on the Collection of CiPoetry from Sui Shan Guan Studio.”Collected Prefaces and Postscripts to the Qing Ci-Poetry.Vol.3.Ed.Feng Qian.Nanjing:Phoenix Publishing House,2013.] 陈水云:《清代词学发展史论》。北京:学苑出版社,2005年。[Chen,Shuiyun.A History of Ci-Poetry Theory Development in the Qing Dynasty.Beijing:Xueyuan Publishing House,2005.] 陈奕禧:《绿阴亭集》,《清代诗文集汇编》第173册。上海:上海古籍出版社,2010年。[Chen,Yixi.Collections of Writings from Green Shade Pavilion Studio.Collected Writings from the Qing Dynasty.Vol.173.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House,2010.] 窦臮:“述书赋下”,《全唐文》第5册,董诰等编。北京:中华书局,2001年。[Dou,Ji.“Comments on Calligraphy.”Vol.2.The Complete Literary Prose from Tang Dynasty.Vol.5.Ed.Dong Hao et al..Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2001.] 邓乔彬:“况周颐‘重、拙、大’说析论”,《中国韵文学刊》6(1992):62-72。[Deng,Qiaobin.“A Study of the Ci-Poetry Theory of Kuang Zhouyi's‘Zhong Zhuo Da’.”Journal of Chinese verse Studies 6(1992):62-72.] 傅山:《霜红龛集》,《清代诗文集汇编》第25册。上海:上海古籍出版社,2010年。[Fu,Shan.Collected Writings from Cream Red Niche.Collected Writings from the Qing Dynasty.Vol.25.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House,2010.] 方智范等:《中国词学批评史》。北京:中国社会科学出版社,1994年。[Fang,Zhifan et al..A History of Chinese Ci-Poetics Criticism.Beijing:China Social Sciences Press,1994.] 顾复初:“苾刍馆词集序”,《清词序跋汇编》第4册,冯乾编校。南京:凤凰出版社,2013年。[Gu,Fuchu.“Introductory Essay on the Collection of CiPoetry from Bi Chu Guan Studio.”Collected Preface and Postscript to the Qing Ci-Poetry.Vol.4.Ed.Feng Qian.Nanjing:Phoenix Publishing House,2013.] 黄霖:《中国文学批评通史·近代卷》。上海:上海古籍出版社,1996年。[Huang,Lin.A History of Modern Literary Criticism.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House,1996.] 蒋兆兰:“词说·自序”,《词话丛编》第5册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Jiang,Zhaolan.“Introductory Essay on the Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.”A Collection of Commentaries on CiPoetry.Vol.5.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 金应珪:“词选后序”,《词话丛编》第2册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Jin,Yinggui.“Epilogue to An Anthology of Ci-Poetry.”ACollection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.2.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 康有为:《广艺舟双楫注》,崔尔平校注。上海:上海书画出版社,2006年。[Kang,Youwei.Annotated Extension of Double Oars for the Boat of Arts.Annotated.Cui Erping.Shanghai:Shanghai Calligraphy and painting Publishing House,2006.] 况周颐:“历代词人考略”,《词话丛编补编》第6册,葛渭君编。北京:中华书局,2013年。[Kuang,Zhouyi.“A Critical Investigation into Ci-Poets across Dynasties.”Supplementary to the Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.6.Ed.Ge Weijun.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2013.] ---:“蕙风词话”,《词话丛编》第5册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[---.“Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Huifeng Studio.”ACollection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.5.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] ---:《况周颐词话五种》,孙克强辑校。杭州:浙江古籍出版社,2014年。[---.Five Anthologies of Kuang Zhouyi's Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Proofread.Sun Keqiang.Hangzhou:Zhejiang Ancient Book Publishing House,2014.] ---:“蕙风词话补编”,《词话丛编补编》第5册,葛渭君编。北京:中华书局,2013年。[---.“Supplement to Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Huifeng Studio.”Supplementary to the Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.5.Ed.Ge Weijun.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2013.] 刘恒:《中国书法史·清代卷》。南京:江苏教育出版社,2015年。[Liu,Heng.A History of Chinese Calligraphy in the Qing Dynasty.Nanjing:Jiangsu Education Publishing House,2015.] 刘熙载:《艺概注稿》下册,袁津琥校注。北京:中华书局,2010年。[Liu,Xizai.Annotated General Principles of Art.Vol.2.Annotated.Yuan Jinhu.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2010.] 龙榆生:“答张孟劬先生”,《龙榆生词学论文集》。上海:上海古籍出版社,2009年。[Long,Yusheng.“A Letter in Reply to Zhang Mengqu.”Collected Essays on Ci-Poetry by Long Yusheng.Shanghai:Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House,2009.] 卢前:“饮虹簃论清词百家”,《清名家词》第十卷,陈乃乾辑。上海:上海书店,1982年。[Lu,Qian.“A Commentary of one Hundred Ci-Poets'CiPoems from Qing Dynasty from Yin Hong Yi Studio.”Famous Ci-Poets from the Qing Dynasty.Vol.10.Ed.Chen Naiqian.Shanghai:Shanghai Bookstore,1982.] 雒三桂:《中国书法史》。北京:人民美术出版社,2009年。[Luo,Sangui.A History of Chinese Calligraphy.Beijing:People's Fine Arts Publishing House,2009.] 马宗霍:《书林藻鉴书林记事》。北京:文物出版社,1984年。[Ma,Zonghuo.Calligraphy Criticism and Record.Beijing:Cultural Relics Publishing House,1984.] 莫云卿:“评书”,《中国古代书论类编》,万宝、黄君编著。合肥:安徽教育出版社,2009年。[Mo,Yunqing.“Calligraphy Commentary.”A Collection of Chinese Ancient Calligraphy Series.Ed.Mao Wanbao and Huang Jun.Hefei:Anhui Education Publishing House,2009.] 潘运告编著:《汉魏六朝书画论》。长沙:湖南美术出版社,1997年。[Pan,Yungao,ed.A Collection of Commentaries on Calligraphy and painting in the Han,Wei and Six Dynasties.Changsha:Hunan Fine Arts Publishing House,1997.] 钱泳:《履园丛话》上册,张伟点校。北京:中华书局,1997年。[Qian,Yong.Collected Writings from LuY uan.Vol.1.Collated.Zhang Wei.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1997.] 阮元:《揅经室集》,邓经元点校。北京:中华书局,2006年。[Ruan,Yuan.A Collection of Writings from Yanjing Studio.Punctuated.Deng Jingyuan.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2006.] 商衍鎏:《清代科举考试述录》。北京:故宫出版社,2014年。[Shang,Yanliu.A Study of the Imperial Examinations in the Qing Dynasty.Beijing:Imperial Palace Publishing House,2014.] 舍我:“天问庐词话”,《词话丛编续编》第4册,朱崇才编纂。北京:人民文学出版社,2010年。[She,Wo.“A Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Tian Wen Lu Studio.”A Sequel to the Series of Collected Ci-Poetry Commentaries.Vol.4.Ed.Zhu Chongcai.Beijing:People's Literature Publishing House,2010.] 苏利海:“‘重拙大’新议”,《文艺理论研究》4(2011):81-85。[Su,Lihai.“A New Study of‘Zhong zhuo Da’.”Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art 4(2011):81-85.] 孙克强:“以梦窗词转移一代风会---晚清四大家推尊吴文英的词学主张及意义”,《河南大学学报》4(2007):1-7。[Sun,Keqiang.“Mengchuang Ci Changed the Style:the Significance of the Canonization of Wu Wen-ying's Ci Theory by the Four Masters in the Late Qing Dynasty.”Journal of Henan University 4(2007):1-7.] ---:“晚清四大家词学集大成论”,《文艺理论研究》3(2006):109-16。[---.“On the Synthesizer Status of Four Masters'Ci-Poetry Theory in the Late Qing Dynasty.”Theoretical Studies in Literature and Art 3(2006):109-16.] ---:《清代词学》。北京:中国社会科学出版社,2004年。[---.The Study of Ci-Poetry in the Qing Dynasty.Beijing:China Social Sciences Publishing House,2004.] 孙维城:“重拙大:桂派词学审美基本标准---况周颐词论研究之一”,《安庆师范学院学报》1(1989):69-75。[Sun,Weicheng.“Zhong Zhuo Da:the Basic Aesthetic Standard of the Lingui School of Ci-Poetry:Studies of Kuang Zhouyi's Ci-Poetry Theory(I).”Journal ofAnqing Normal University 1(1989):69-75.] ---:“清季四大词人词学取向与重拙大之关系”,《文学评论》5(2007):169-74。[---.“The relationship between the trends of Four Masters'Ci-Poetry Theory in the Late Qing Dynasty and‘Zhong Zhuo Da’.”Literary Review 5(2007):169-74.] 谭献:“重辑复堂词话”,《词话丛编补编》第2册,葛渭君编。北京:中华书局,2013年。[Tan,Xian.“Re-collection of Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Fu Tang.”Supplementary to the Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.2.Ed.Ge Weijun.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2013.] ---:“复堂词话”,《词话丛编》第4册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[---.“Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Fu Tang.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.4.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 王鹏运:“彊村词原序”,《清词序跋汇编》第4册,冯乾编校。南京:凤凰出版社,2013年。[Wang,Pengyun.“Preface to Ci-Poetry from Jiangcun.”Collected Preface and Postscript to the Qing Ci-Poetry.Vol.4.Ed.Feng Qian.Nanjing:Phoenix Publishing House,2013.] 王水照:“况周颐与王国维:不同的审美范式”,《文学遗产》2(2008):4-16。[Wang,Shuizhao.“Kuang Zhouyi and Wang Guowei:Different Aesthetic Paradigms.”Literary Heritage 2(2008):4-16.] 吴宏一:《清代词学四论》。台北:联经事业出版公司,1990年。[Wu,Hongyi.Four Treatises on Ci-Poetics in the Qing Dynasty.Taipei:Linking Publishing Company,1990.] 夏静观:“蕙风词话诠评”,《词话丛编》第5册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Xia,Jingguan.“A commentary of Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Huifeng Studio.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.5.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 项穆:《书法雅言》。北京:中华书局,1985年。[Xiang,Mu.A Commentaries of Calligraphy(Shu Fa Ya Yan).Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,1985.] 谢章铤:“赌棋山庄词话续编”,《词话丛编》第4册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Xie,Zhangting.“Ci-Poetry Commentaries from the ChessBetting Villa the Second Sequel.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.4.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 宣雨苍:“词谰”,《词话丛编续编》第4册,朱崇才编纂。北京:人民文学出版社,2010年。[Xuan,Yucang.“A Collection of False Commentaries on Cipoetry.”A Sequel to the Series of Collected Ci-Poetry Commentaries.Vol.4.Ed.Zhu Chongcai.Beijing:People's Literature Publishing House,2010.] 赵尊岳:“《蕙风词话》跋”,《蕙风词话广蕙风词话》附录一,孙克强辑考。郑州:中州古籍出版社,2003年。[Zhao,Zunyue.“Postscript to Ci-Poetry Commentaries from Huifeng Studio.”Commentaries on Ci-Poems of Huifeng and Guang Huifeng.Ed.Sun Keqiang.Zhengzhou:Zhongzhou Ancient Book Publishing House,2003.] 郑文焯:“与张孟劬书”,《绝妙好词校录》附录三“大鹤山人遗札”,《词话丛编补编》第5册,葛渭君编。北京:中华书局,2013年。[Zheng,Wenzhuo.“A letter to Zhang Mengqu.”“Posthumous letters by Great Crane Hermit.”Zheng Wenzhuo.Proofread Wonderful good Ci-poetry.Supplement to the Collection of Commentaries on CiPoetry.Vol.5.Ed.Ge Weijun.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2013.] 《中国书法发展史》,中国教育学会书法教育专业委员会编。天津:天津古籍出版社,2009年。[The Development History of Chinese Calligraphy.Ed.Chinese Education Association Calligraphy Education Specialized Committee.Tianjin:Tianjin Ancient Books Publishing House,2009.] 周济:“介存斋论词杂著”,《词话丛编》第2册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[Zhou,Ji.“Commentaries on Ci-Poetry from Jiecui Studio.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.2.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] ---:“宋四家词选目录序论”,《词话丛编》第2册,唐圭璋编。北京:中华书局,2005年。[---.“Introductory Essay on the Collected Ci-Poems from Four Poets in Song Dynasty.”A Collection of Commentaries on Ci-Poetry.Vol.2.Ed.Tang Guizhang.Beijing:Zhonghua Book Company,2005.] 朱孝臧:“守白词乙稿跋”,《清词序跋汇编》第4册,冯乾编校。南京:凤凰出版社,2013年。[Zhu,Xiaozang.“Postscript to the Second Collection of Cipoetry from Shoubai.”Collected Preface and Postscript to the Qing Ci-Poetry.Vol.4.Ed.Feng Qian.Nanjing:Phoenix Publishing House,2013.] (1)参见苏利海:“‘重拙大’新议”(《文艺理论研究》4(2011):81-85)关于“重拙大”内涵阐释的学术史梳理。 (2)刘红麟曾引用蔡嵩云对“重拙大”的解释,并认为“基本能概括王鹏运重拙大之旨”,惜未发挥蔡氏将其与碑学联系起来的观点。参见刘红麟《晚清四大词人研究》(长沙:湖南师范大学出版社,2012年),第34页。 (3)这一点与词学的使用与阐释情况略同,如孙克强:《况周颐“重、拙、大”新论》一文中说:“对于‘重、拙、大’的内涵,《蕙风词话》正续编中已有所解释,但详略不同,如释‘重、拙’较详,而释‘大’较略”。参见《中国韵文学刊》2(2003):91-95。 (4)关于临桂词派的形成与词学主张可参巨传友《清代临桂词派研究》(上海:上海古籍出版社,2008年)的相关论述。 (5)清词研究专家严迪昌在《清词流派述要》一文种就说:“‘桂派’的词学观,渊源仍在‘常州词派’,是‘常派’的余波一脉”。参见王步高编《金元明清词鉴赏辞典》附录(南京:南京大学出版社,1989年),第1 388页。 (6)陈水云在《清代词学发展史论》(北京:学苑出版社,2005年,第247页)中说谭献对词创作技巧提出的两点要求之一便是“运笔多样化,或平起(正笔),或重笔,或逆入平出(侧笔)”。 (7)华人德在《中国书法史·两汉卷》(南京:江苏教育出版社,1999年)中说:“清代碑学派书家用笔多主张逆入平出,即是隶书笔法”。参见第155页。 (8)参见彭玉平:“晚清‘重拙大’词学思想溯源---端木埰《宋词赏心录》探论”,《学术研究》8(2004):127-31。 (9)赵尊岳《〈蕙风词话〉跋》就称况周颐言词境“其造极者曰穆”。参见况周颐著、孙克强辑考《蕙风词话广蕙风词话》附录一(郑州:中州古籍出版社,2003年),第452页。 (10)据龙榆生《今日学词应取之途径》转述朱祖谋语,《龙榆生词学论文集》(上海:上海古籍出版社,2009年),第115页。 (11)孙维城在“重拙大:桂派词学审美基本标准---况周颐词论研究之一”一文说:“可知‘意厚’云云,乃在意多”,是颇为准确的观点。参见《安庆师范学院学报》1(1989):69-76。 (12)孙维城将况周颐的“重”视为“气格”,并认为它与明清的“格调”说、先秦汉魏的“文气”说存在渊源关系,即为显例。参见孙维城:“重拙大:桂派词学审美基本标准---况周颐词论研究之一”,《安庆师范学院学报》1(1989):69-76。 |